Jeb
2008-01-17 15:47:05
TomB,
Yes, in fact I pointed out that strongest criticism of the article was their reliance on news reports for identifying perpetrators. I also pointed out that stronger criticisms of the methodology were included in the article than were present in the comments. I see that after reading the article you picked up on one of them (Colonel Melnyk made that point in the article in question). Regarding the tone, I think your vew is colored by your preconceived notions.
