A Comment About

Valkyrie’s Revisionism

January 8, 2009 - 12:17 am - by John Rosenthal
wlpeak
2009-01-08 11:56:46

@Bill Peron

I am a skeptic who sees the efficacy of the Darwinian evolutionary model and doesn’t believe in a deity. Indeed I would even consider myself a relativist. But I would never vilify someone for making an honest attempt to argue a position. That’s just uncivil and counterproductive.

As for the movie, it was an enjoyable romp but shouldn’t be venerated or scrutinized too closely. Also I disagree that Tom was a convincing example of an aristocratic officer.

Those who get their history from movies are condemned to repeats.