I think the issue is that Joe the Plumbers concerns have been addressed by both candidates. Under Obama’s plan, any money he makes over $250,000 would be taxed at an additional 3%. But Joe the Plumber has said to the media that Obama did a song and dance, referencing Sammy Davis Jr, no less, and didn’t answer his question. This leads one to think that Joe the Plumber isn’t interested in hearing and considering an answer re: his taxes under Obama, but is rather looking for information to reinforce his prior position, a Republican position. That suggests that he was never really interested in hearing what Obama had to say. It’s the lack of seeming practical reasoning and thoughtful consideration on his part, at least in regard to what he’s said publicly, that is being debated. And can I add that he’s agreed to continue this conversation with the media?
