A Comment About

Mano a mano: Spencer v Derbyshire

August 23, 2007 - 11:45 am - by Robert Spencer
Abu Allah
2007-08-23 16:34:46

David, I’ll ask you again? Did you actually comprehend anything I wrote? Where did I say that I thought only Muslims are violent? I certainly believe that individual Christians, Jews and others can be violent, but not due to the current teachings and practices of their religious movements. Islamic terrorist groups are religious movements, who act directly on violent imperialist, expansionist, and supremacist dogma being spouted in Mosques all over the world, every day. You simply cannot show me the equivalent of that coming from any other major religious movement in the world today I asked you to show me the Christian and Jewish militias and terrorist groups following Mr. Spencer’s marching orders and you bring up the American presence in Iraq. Last time I checked the United States is a secular democratic republic, and its military is soldiered by Christians, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, Atheists, and probably other religious groups as well. Not exactly an analog of Hamas or Abu Sayyef, huh? Next you’ll be telling me I should watch out for Jewish members of Al Qaida I suppose? The fact that you brought up Iraq also shows your ignorance on this entire debate. If you had actually been to Jihadwatch as you claimed and read even briefly, you would realize that Mr. Spencer and Jihadwatch vice president Hugh Fitzgerald are fiercely opposed to the war in Iraq, and therefor the use of it to attempt to defame Mr. Spencer and his views is at least as worthless as the other fallacies that you have tried to peddle in your previous posts.