Get PJ Media on your Apple

Will the AZ Immigration Law Make the Job of Police Harder?

A group of police chiefs — including L.A.'s Charlie Beck — say that illegal aliens will be more reluctant to help fight crime out of fear of law enforcement.

by
Jack Dunphy

Bio

May 28, 2010 - 12:00 am
<- Prev  Page 2 of 2   View as Single Page

Oddly enough, it was Bratton who chose to leave California last year.  He resigned his post in the middle of his second five-year contract rather than remain in office to confront the budgetary constraints now facing Chief Beck.  And a large factor in the fiscal woes plaguing the city of Los Angeles and the state of California is the financial burden attendant to an exploding population of  illegal immigrants.

For all the hysteria being whipped up by Beck and his fellow Arizona-bashers, there is little likelihood the new law will have the disastrous consequences being predicted.  Beck foresaw higher crime should the Arizona law take effect, telling reporters that “legislation like this inhibits us from doing our jobs” and will dissuade immigrants from coming forward as victims and witnesses.  “The fear of the police already inhibits immigrants from coming forward to a certain extent,” he said. “But if you add this piece you increase the reluctance tenfold.”

It is no doubt true that some illegal immigrants are reluctant to speak to the police, but it has been my experience that they are less fearful of being deported than they are of being retaliated against by criminal gang members, a large number of whom are themselves illegal immigrants.  Yes, the new Arizona law brings the potential for error and even abuse, but that potential exists in every aspect of police work, and we don’t ask police officers to ignore violations of the law because they might make a mistake.

My guess is that police officers in Arizona, when armed with this new law, will concentrate their efforts on those illegal immigrants whose criminal predations fall most heavily on their law-abiding neighbors.  Had such a law been in place in Texas a few years ago, Houston police officer Henry Canales might be alive today.  The men accused of murdering him last year, both  illegal immigrants with criminal records, are today on trial in Houston.  The Houston Chronicle reported on their arrest last year:

Capital murder charges have been filed against Andres Maldonado Nava, 41, of Mexico, and Xiomara Mendez Rosales, 36, of Honduras.

According to Ken Land-grebe, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement official, Maldonado had used eight false identities between 1985 and 1992, and was arrested in California between 1990 and 1992 for attempted murder, robbery, being under the influence of drugs, grand theft, assault and exhibiting a firearm. Mendez, authorities said, was arrested in Houston on charges of assault of a family member in 2006, but the charges were dismissed.

A recent violent crime in the state of Washington has produced a man who may be the single most gleaming example that demonstrates just how pathetically impotent our immigration enforcement system is.  Jose Lopez Madrigal was arrested in Edmond, Wash., on May 16 and charged with rape.  Seattle’s KING television reported that Madrigal had previously been deported nine times:

[L]earning [Madrigal’s] identity took much longer because of some 30 aliases. It was only through fingerprints that they identified him as Madrigal, a Mexican citizen.

Madrigal’s arrest and immigration record includes a staggering number of contacts with law enforcement since 1989. That’s the year he was convicted of theft using a firearm in California.

He was deported a couple of times after that. Then in 1999, he was arrested for drug sales in both San Diego and San Francisco. Records show that he was deported three times that year between April and August.

He was arrested for drugs again in Stockton, Calif. in 2000. In 2002, he pleaded to third degree sexual assault in Denver. Later that year, he was deported again. And in 2003, records show he was deported three more times.

Police allege that Madrigal dragged a woman off an Edmond street and was in the process of raping her next to a trash Dumpster when officers, alerted to the crime by a witness, arrested him.

I suspect if we were to ask that rape victim her opinion of Arizona’s new law, she would offer a hearty endorsement.  Would Chief Beck tell her she’s wrong?

<- Prev  Page 2 of 2   View as Single Page
Jack Dunphy is the pseudonym of a police officer in Southern California.
Click here to view the 65 legacy comments

Comments are closed.