UN Circulating Document Alleging Israelis ‘Harvesting Human Organs’
The International Organization for the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination (EAFORD), a Libyan-founded non-governmental organization, has submitted a document to the Geneva-based United Nations Human Rights Council — the body that commissioned the Goldstone Report, which alleged Israel was guilty of war crimes in Gaza — to investigate allegations that “Israeli physicians, Medical Centres, rabbis and the Israeli army” may be stealing the organs of “dead, kidnapped and killed” Palestinians for sale on the black market.
The document has been circulated by the Human Rights Council as Agenda item 7 for the body’s thirteenth session (A/HRC/13/NGO/23), and although it has been covered by the Jerusalem Post and Canada’s National Post, no British media outlet has so far reported on it.
EAFORD was accredited as an NGO by the UN in 1981, and its focus, judging by its website and publications, is on equating Zionism with racism and South African apartheid.
Its present submission had been screened for publication by the UN’s Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, a post currently held by Navanethem Pillay, and granted the certified logo of the United Nations.
By way of introduction, EAFORD accuses Israel of “ethnic cleansing and massacres” against the Palestinians, “occupy[ing] the rest of Palestine,” creating the “largest open-air prison in the world,” whose “consequences amount to an act of siege and economic genocide.”
EAFORD then proceeds to state the following:
It is the turn of the dead, kidnapped and killed Palestinians. Their human organs, as reported in the press, can be a source of immense wealth through illegal trafficking in the world market. Israeli physicians, Medical Centres, rabbis and the Israeli army may to be involved, according to reports published in the Swedish press and criminal investigations in the United States. After Israeli physicians remove organs they think marketable, the soldiers bury the bodies in graves that carry only numbers and no names, or place them in sealed caskets and deliver them under curfew conditions to the families and supervise the digging of the graves and burial.
The document went on to call for an international boycott of Israeli doctors and medical centres, for UN Secretary General Kai Ban Moon to refer the allegation to the UN Security Council and the Prosecutor at the International Criminal Court of Justice, and for the Human Rights Council to authorize its Special Fact Finding Commission to investigate Israel’s supposed organ theft.
The basis for EAFORD’s accusation is the Swedish newspaper Aftonbladet’s August 28, 2009, article entitled “Our sons are plundered of their organs” in which writer Donald Bostrom suggested that Israeli soldiers were killing Palestinians in the West Bank for the purpose of organ theft and sale within Israel. Bostrom wrote:
We know that Israel has a great need for organs, that there is a vast and illegal trade of organs which has been running for many years now, that the authorities are aware of it and that doctors in managing positions at the big hospitals participate, as well as civil servants at various levels. We also know that young Palestinian men disappeared, that they were brought back after five days, at night, under tremendous secrecy, stitched back together after having been cut from abdomen to chin.
Bostrom later appeared on CNN to say that he had no proof of any of the outrageous insinuations made in his article and relied solely on testimony of Palestinians. Nevertheless, his story was picked up and recycled on leading Arab news channels such as Al Jazeera and Al-Arabiya, prompting at least one fabricated report, in the Algerian daily El-Khabar, that Interpol had uncovered a “Jewish gang” said to be “involved in the abduction of children from Algeria and trafficking of their organs.”
In reporting on the UN’s certification of what the EAFORD document states, the National Post noted that the Human Rights Council is complicit in the document’s composition:
In contrast to what the UN reviewers approved for the EAFORD statement, they told UN Watch [a Geneva-based group that monitors the UN for its perceived bias against Israel] recently not to use the word “regime” when referring to the governments of Sudan, Burma, Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Zimbabwe because it would offend those countries, said Hillel Neuer, the group’s executive director.
It is remarkable that the UN’s circulation of EAFORD’s document has not been cited by the British press insofar as the “Israeli organ theft” allegation was cited by Baroness Jenny Tonge, who was quoted in the Palestine Telegraph newspaper, of which she is a patron, reaffirming the need for Israel to establish an inquiry into claims that its human relief workers in post-earthquake Haiti had harvested victims’ organs for use in Israeli transplants. Baroness Tonge’s statement was widely reported in the UK, as was the consequence of it: she was sacked as the Liberal Democrats health spokesperson in the House of Lords in light of what Nick Clegg, the party’s leader, described as her “unacceptable comments.”






And yet, Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank clamor to get treated in Israeli hospitals.
Their own leaders are incapable of providing decent health care (possibly because all those billions of euros/dollars in EU/USA aid is instead spent on rockets and Swiss bank accounts), yet they are getting creative in slandering Israeli medicine.
So – instead of using this document as evidence of blood libel against the Jews, they are actually seriously considering it as a TRUTHFUL document proving that Israel, and by extension Jews, prey upon sweet little innocent Palestinians? The mind boggles. WTH is WRONG with these people? Is this a mote-beam issue?
The sheer stupidity and willful ignorance on this subject is just appalling. The same FALSE accusations were made about americans “shopping” for organs in third world countries a few years ago, leading to assaults and deaths of innocent tourists. There has NEVER been (as in this case) any proof of this actually happening.
In order for an organ transplant to have any chance of success, the tissues MUST BE matched between donor and recipient. This would be impossible to do under battlefield conditions.
Are the “donors” in healthy condition? I doubt it. What could be more foolish than transplanting a diseased or infected organ?
The fact that this is considered worth investigating is just one more proof of UN stupidity and anti-semitism.
The document circulating at the UN seems to me to be in line with the UNHRC bias against Israel.
But there was also a report by msnbc in which a certain Dr. Jehuda Hiss of a forensic center in Israel said that this practice had taken place in the 90s but ceased in 2000.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/34503294/ns/world_news-mideastn_africa/
So why is the UNHRC allowing the EAFORD document to be circulated under the official UN certification? To stir things up, provocate, spread rumours…
If I was a victim of human rights violations in one of the many countries today where such violations are rampant, I certainly wouldn’t harbor any hope of assistance from the UNHRC. They are scandal and embarrassment.
No way, this is a crock.
It just wouldn’t be Kosher.
It’s time for the U.N. to go the way of the League of Nations.
It is time for an Entebbe-style raid on the UN offices in Geneva. This is a terrorist organization and Israel must treat it as such.
….And, they are not dealing with this document as a product of the advertising campaign outlined in the Hamas Covenant?
It’s ok to slander Jews. They’re not important…after all, Mr. Obama has received all sorts of kudos in the Muslim world for his slights and insults to Isreal and Jews in general.
Well, it just goes to show you that no good deed goes unpunished. Israel gives Palestinians free medical care despite the constant rocket and mortar attacks on Israeli homes and schools. Israel should immediately stop all medical aid to the Palestinians, remove all Palestinians from Israeli hospitals and care units, refuse to allow doctors, or ambulances in Israel to treat Palestinians, and announce that from this day forward all Palestinians must be treated by their own doctors.
Since according to the UN Israel is mistreating the poor dears, the UN should fully approve of this.
Tell me again why the US should continue to support the UN?
There is a law here in Florida allowing coroners to ‘harvest’ corneas without family consent….I’m an ophthalmologist.
Perhaps most disturbing is that there are media outlets who allow this type of character attacks to go on. In some cases, they support it. In others, their silence supports it, by remaining silent. Organ transplants do not happen under most of the conditions Palestinians die. Those who die in hospital should be photographed before return to their families. If this goes on & is permitted credibility, then Israel really should stop treating Palestinians so such actions could never take place.
Attempting to discredit Israeli Doctors or medical aid to earthquake victims, is about as despicable as it gets. Apparently, these folks want the world to reject Israeli help. So bet it. Let them. Israeli’s can still contribute materials.
One must remember, the folks making these specious accusations are also the ones who asserted America was trying to occupy or take over Haiti. Why would America want a nation that will require literally tens of billions to reconstruct? Its too expensive. Yet even some leaders of a major European nation implied such.
So long as there are media outlets whose objectives are to denounce & discredit those they hate, we will have this stuff. Seems to me, such actions & especially by the UN, only justify the calls to de-fund the UN & allow it to whither into the obscurity it deserves if it keeps up this lie & distortion campaign.
Could the UN (or officers thereof) be indicted at The Hague for incitement to racism?
or: I notice that a lawsuit in Kentucky is trying to have the Pope deposed (maybe we’ll see how well those Swiss Guards can fight, huh?) But if the Pope for pedophile-coverup, then why not Ban Ki-Moon et al for racism? Serious question/no sarc.
“1. dsch:
And yet, Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank clamor to get treated in Israeli hospitals.”
Well, DUH! That’s where the organs are!
It’s just like when Willy Sutton, famous bank robber, was asked why he robbed banks, he said, “Because that’s where the money is.”
The idea of Israelis or Jews stealing human organs for transplant or consumption in festival foods is a blood libel that goes back centuries and ignorant people (anti-Semites, Muslims) have been buying into it for just as long.