The Hicks File: Flotilla of Fools
This past weekend, a six-ship flotilla left Turkey bound for the Hamas-controlled Gaza Strip. They never made it — they were intercepted by the Israeli military. Details are still being collected, but it looks like at least nine people were killed.
The international uproar was instantaneous. Israel, they said, was again being the bully. According to them, this was just a humanitarian mission to bring aid to the hard-pressed residents of Gaza and those on board the Mavi Marmara were surprised by a brutal, unprovoked attack.
Hold it. Let’s get real! This is the same old anti-Israel bias coming from European Union leaders who fall all over themselves to show disdain for Israel but never lose an opportunity to show support for their favorite international victims: Palestinians and Muslims.
Within hours, Spain and France concluded that what the Jewish state did was “excessive.” Spain called the actions “unacceptable” and French President Nicolas Sarkozy said he “condemns the disproportionate use of force.” Meanwhile, Great Britain called for Israel to drop its long-standing blockade of Gaza.
After stripping away the anti-Israel rhetoric, here is what’s known about this incident:
There is general agreement that six ships — self-described as a “freedom flotilla” — left Turkey with “supplies” for Gaza. After this, there’s lots of disagreement.
Turkey, who backed the blockade-busters, says the supplies were benign: largely food, medicines, and clothing. They also say the 600 people on board the ships were unarmed “peacemakers.”
Despite what the Turks say, that’s unlikely. But let’s clear up a thing or two.
First, according to the Oslo Accords, the Israelis have sovereignty over Gaza, and international law allows nations to require suspicious ships to identify themselves before entering their waters. International law also requires that ships of the kind involved in this incident conform — in this case — to Israel’s laws and security needs.
Second, Israel simply can’t allow unknown goods to enter into Gaza, a territory controlled by Hamas. This is after all a terrorist regime that calls for the murder of Jews, the “obliteration” of Israel, and its replacement with an Islamic theocracy.
It’s also important to point out that in the past, Israel has intercepted ships and boats with weapons intended for Hamas. Prior to building the security wall, Hamas was responsible for 40 percent of all suicide attacks against Israeli citizens, and over 10,000 rockets have been launched by Hamas from Gaza against communities in southern Israel since 2005.
This is a high-stakes game — one that Israel can’t afford to lose.
It is also important to get a clear picture of the organization claiming responsibility for this so-called “freedom flotilla.”
The group that claims it organized the flotilla is the Foundation for Human Rights and Freedoms and Humanitarian Relief, better known as IHH. Formed in 1992, its based in Turkey with offices in Gaza and the West Bank.
However, while the IHH may have an innocent-sounding name, it has documented ties to terrorists and was named in federal court documents as playing a role in the Los Angeles millennium bomb plot. Intelligence reports from 1996 also linked this Turkish group to international terrorism. An Israeli intelligence report also linked this group to “radical Islamic networks,” including Hamas, and other global jihad networks.
Steve Emerson, who has appeared on PJTV and is a respected terrorism expert, says that IHH was banned by Israel in 2008 for its affiliation with Hamas and its association with Muslim Brotherhood leader Yousef al-Qaradawi, who issued a fatwa calling for the killing of Americans and Jews.
Little wonder then, that some on board these ships, boarded by Israeli commandos, were in a fighting mood. Despite verbal warnings and attempts to prevent violence, these “humanitarians” reportedly attacked Israeli commandos with clubs, knives, and guns when they boarded the ship At this point the surprised commandos were forced to respond with lethal force just to protect themselves.
It’s worth pointing out that American leftists have been involved in past attempts to evade Israel’s blockade. One of America’s most visible lunatic leftists, Cynthia McKinney, was involved in (count ‘em) two “Free Gaza Movement” flotilla attempts in 2008 and again in 2009. This is the same foolish former congresswoman who used anti-Semitic language in a 2002 election campaign, claimed President Bush had advanced warning of the 9/11 terrorist attacks, and attacked a Capital Hill police officer in 2006.
Nonetheless, even some conservatives have argued that maybe the Israeli military attack on the blockade-busters was a mistake that fed into the hands of Israel’s enemies.
Perhaps, but I think Israel is always in a damned-if-you-do, damned-if-you-don’t position.
Despite the fact that Hamas controls Gaza and declares its hatred for Jews and all things Jewish, just during the first three months of this year, Israel allowed the transfer of almost 95,000 tons of supplies into Gaza — supplies which included food, clothes, shoes, milk, and baby food.
Yet they’ve been defined as occupiers and “Nazis” by Muslim activists and organizations of the international hard-left.
Faced with a flotilla organized by a Hamas ally, what do the second-guessers think Israel should have done? They offer little in the way of realistic alternatives.
The argument is that Israel is guilty of using disproportional force when responding to attacks. This has been said repeatedly, including during Israel’s last two military responses to terrorists’ attacks: the 2006 war against Hezbollah and Operation Defensive Shield in 2002.
But look, there really is a well-defined effort to destroy Israel. One threat comes from Iran, where a regime is in place that makes no secret of its intent to wipe Israel off the map. Then there’s Hamas — the government of record in Gaza and a hateful group of terrorist thugs that’s sent over 10,000 missiles into Israel.
Yet elites at the United Nations and in the capitals of Western Europe think Israel should exercise restraint and — if it must — respond proportionately. That’s complete and utter BS!
Me? I’ll stand with Israel.






Some seem to think that the fact that some of those who died had been shot more than once proves that Israel not only was the aggressor but attacked unarmed and innocent people.
Ever see the aftermath of a police shootout. It’s rare for someone to be shot just once.
As to being shot in the head, I’m guessing the commandos are good enough shots that they can go for the head instead of a center of mass shot. Good for them.
As to being shot a close range. The entire riot took place on the top deck of a medium sized ship. There was no long range to be had.
Sorry but in training usually at least two shots to the body are part of the routine, and if body armor is suspected two to the head. I think the IDA used great restraint since after the pipe or bars started hitting the troops only nine are dead.
Mr. Hicks: I agree with you that they are a bunch fools who were taken advanteg of… and that is why the murderous Israeli military shot them point blank!! what a great way of defending a country!!! murder people point blank and we Americans give you 20 million dollars a day of our federal taxes!! that is a great deal! don’t you think?
I love the way miriam’s lies get bigger with each passing day.
Yesterday they were shot at close range. Now it’s point blank.
Hatred rots the mind, and miriams is long gone.
Shot them at point blank range. What is point blank range? You know that is one the favorite lies the Hamas has…..Shot them in the head at point blank range….. That’s the same song and dance they used in the last war. It doesn’t change, only the fools who quote them change. They even had xrays to show bullets in a brain. That was debunked here on PJM by trauma doctors and experts on ballistics. The only person who seems to have any brain damage is a certain muslim who keeps quoting the Palliwood lies.
Let’s rename the chief hate boat
(600 useful idiots to deliver 10 tons?)
THE MAVI MIRIAM in honor of the chief pyjama troll.
(Sorry David Stein, but you get the Cuban cigar.)
This is well writen summary of the situation. The writer understand the nature of Israels enemy. The Leftist press will rush to blame Israel despite any evidence to the contrary. The truth just gets in the way.
The ships were carrying Islamic Jihadist mercenary terrorists.
The IDF were armed with paint ball guns!
Israel was carrying out a search of a private vessel in accordance with maritime law and procedures. The ships captain would know this. But the IDF were met with deadly force and reacted in self defence. The world media and politicians reacted with the usual anti-semitic zeal.
In the end, Hamas refused to accept the ‘aid’. They have no need for it.
The whole episode was a propoganda exercise to demonise and deligitimise Israel.
Utterly shameful.
Israel has every right to blockade Hamas ruled Gaza and have followed the rules of a blockade in international waters to the letter. These Islamic terrorists aboard the Marmara shouting “Khaibar! Khaibar!” – a reference to a Muslim massacre of Jews in the Arabian peninsula in the seventh century – were prepared for a fight and Israel gave them one.
It is worth noting that in the recent past, Israeli forces have diverted nine such flotillas, all without incident, and peacefully boarded five of the ships in this week’s convoy. Their cargoes, after proper inspection, were delivered to non-Hamas institutions in Gaza. Only the Marmara violently resisted. It is no coincidence that the ship was dispatched by Insani Yardim Vakfi (also called the I.H.H.), a supposed Islamic charity that Israeli and other intelligence services have linked to Islamic extremists and terrorists.
Israel has nothing to apologize for just as we do not need to apologize ever for killing Al Qaeda terrorists in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Like Israel, we are facing an implacable foe who wants to kill us all for the way we think and believe. There are 3000 dead Americans in New York as testament to that desire.
It is also worth remembering that some 50 years ago, when faced with the threat of nuclear weapons being installed in Cuba, President Kennedy took us and the world to the brink of Armageddon with a blockade of Russian ships in international waters. Since that time America has rightly maintained an embargo on communist Cuba.
Implacable enemies are to be stepped on, not negotiated with.
Go Israel…….
The writer has it spot on. The ship was boarded in accordance with maritime law and procedures. The attack on the IDF was illegal and an act of attempted murder. The IDF acted in self defence. The world press are guilty of anti-semitism and blood libel. They failed to let the truth get in the way of their venomous hatred of Israel. Utterly shameful.
miriams just upset because no jews died.
Because I am not a public representative, I cannot say that I can formally speak on behalf of my fellow Irish countrymen and women. However, as an Irishman, I can say that I am seriously embarrassed by the “Rachel Corrie” and what it stands for. I can also apologise on behalf all those Irish people who feel like I do – and there are many of us, despite the biased portrayal by our media. I apologise profoundly to the people of Israel for the appalling, racist, bigoted, self-serving, presumptuous, publicity-seeking, propagandist, supporters of those who seek to destroy Israel – and then the rest of the non-Islamic world. I simply cannot understand these nincompoops; but then, I suppose they have a hard job understanding even themselves. Long Live Israel! Éamonn, Dublin, Ireland.
7. Éamonn, Dublin
Thanks a million Eamonn (sorry, I can’t do the accent).
I have been wondering for some time why the Irish hate the Jews:
Mary Robinson, a couple of Corrigans, Falk (?), etc.
Is it the Roman Catholicism and ‘the Jews crucified him’ syndrome?
Or were there hundreds of Shylockian money lenders in Eire?
It’s good to know that there is ONE non-antisemitic Irishman,
willing to speak up. Would that others do the same.
Thanks again.
Back to the thread.
#6 MarkThe Great… you got that one wrong…. I date a Jew… so here you are…. and guess what her last name is Kaplan.. and guess what I am a muslim… there you have it… have a great weekend
Miriam Rove – raise your children as Jews. They will respect you as a mother and as a woman.
Miriam Rove – you must be a liberated Muslim, since a Muslim woman with connections to her community would be subject to the death penalty. Men can marry “out” but women cannot, as you no doubt know.
Miriam Rove – your views are unbalanced. You must be suffering from your liberation from Islam. What better way to show you are still part of the group than by hating Jews.
Miriam Rove – I will bet dollars to donuts that you cannot list ten good things about Israel and the Jews. If you cannot, what does that say about the way your mind works.
Of course, there is the possibility that you are making up the whole story, so easy on the Internet. I will never know!
so, miriam, it’s no problem that you are muslim and your girl friend, ms. kaplan, is jewish? how about the islamic view of homosexual relations? or is that a non-issue??
8. miriam rove
MarkTheGreat’s comment is still valid.
Especially since you claim to be a mohammedan.
On the web, who knows; you could be a 300lb Sumo wrestler.
Heck!, you could be a 300lb Sumo wrestler muslim lesbian.
With a moustache.
So, Miriam Gayslim, you practice your faith and don’t hate Jews.
How come?
Your religion is supposed to surmount EVERYTHING else.
Love vs Islam? Islam is first.
State vs Islam? Islam is first.
National Law vs Islam? Islam is first.
You are enjoined: “the trees and rocks shall say – ‘Oh muslim, there is a Jew behind me. Come and kill him.’”
As in the Charter of Hamas, legally elected government of Gaza.
ANYTHING less, and you are an apostate. Good luck!
With a ‘religion of peace’ like that, who needs a religion of war?
Am I the only American who doesn’t care about the crazy religious war in Israel/Gaza? From my standpoint, it’s obvious that both sides are equally guilty.
Besides, the ships didn’t have any actual weapons. That much is obvious. Also, aren’t there any repercussions for Israel in attacking a ship from a NATO country?
“Also, aren’t there any repercussions for Israel in attacking a ship from a NATO country?”
Nope. No more than for arresting a terrorist with a passport from a NATO country, or the USCG seizing a Canadian-flagged drugrunner.
Let’s recap for the slow learners. Hamas has sent how many rockets? 7,000? Now, there is a blockaid to help keep arms out of Hamas’s hands, and perhaps some C4 jackets.
It is war, and Israel should defend it’s people by every means they have.
Today, the PM of Turkey called for a city in Israel to be destroyed. See Debkafile.
The last time a mooon god worshiping PM shouted destruction for the Jews 250,000 people lost their lives from great waves. 2006?
Anyway, I’m going out on a limb here, and state watch Turkey get hit with something over the top. Like weather, or an earthquake soon. Real soon. I could be wrong, but these last ten years seem to have a pattern to them.
As one of Irish ancestry and one who does hold an Irish passport I am perplexed by the attitudes of the Irish in their craven support for Palestinians and their terrorism. Maybe the Irish who created the IRA one of the most murderous political groups in the world just feel a natural affiliation with the worst terrorists in the mid East. Or do the educated Irish yuppies feel guilty about their new found wealth and insist on their inane vacationing in other people’s miseries.
You know, I am all for democracy and I support the freedom of the internet, but sometimes I wish that, in order for people to post comments there were (instead of the requirement to provide e-mail addresses and the like) logical tests. For example:
#9 not quite there ExtraStout.Apologists for Islam and terrorists have been repeating your line for at least 20 years.Both sides are not equally guilty.Hamas has no reason for existance.Like Hezbollah.If you dont care then why are you here?ill tell you why.Because you cant stand the thought of Israel being correct in this scenario.Just like shes correct in 1948,1956,1967,1973 and 1982,2000,2007,2009,and 2010.Did i miss any dates?Yes i did 1972 munich,Black semptember PALISTINIAN group.So youll pardon me while i suspect Palestinian and Islamic rulers of this world.
What about the fathers, mothers, sons and grandsons murdered by MUSLIMS on 9-11???
Go Israel Go!
As this struggle goes on, term “terrorist” has less and less residual PR value, and Israel seems to be at its wits’ end trying to get any kind of energy out of it. Perhaps it’s time to start calling the Hamas crowd “suspected drug dealers”, “gangsters”, or even “slave traders”. “Terrorists” isn’t doing the job any more.
jerry:
I have 4 sons one of whom is a Marine in Afghanistan and i brought them without religion and that is why they are happy.
I am not a liberated muslim rather a very smart athiest who belives the biggest BS created is god and religion
my views are very balanced and I don hate Jews or anyone to that matter
as for listing 10 things about Jews and Israel..let me just mention two things and hopefully this will clear things up
persian empire fell,greek empire fell/roma empire fell/alexander the great fell/ottoman empire fell/jews have been murdered and persecuted for centuries but Jews survived all of this and that is why I amdire them…
second- I deal with orthodox jews on a daily basis in Brooklyn New york… I can put ten million dollars in business on the table on a friday afternoon they will not touch it with a ten foot pole as they go home for sabath.. this only shows how genuine they are
as for Israel… I would love to go Jeruslam and Haifa.. I hear it is beatiful. and no I am not making this up and I i think you are intelligent enough to see it.
yrmother.. why bring religion to the mix? how about catholics church’s view on homosexuality? your poin is pointless….. I don’t give a flyin f…..if a guy wants to f….another guy up the a…..what do i care..
Yet, you did say you were a moslem in a previous post.
“and guess what I am a muslim”
You have a female name and say you have a girlfriend, and say you are a moslem. Islam calls for homosexuals (including lesbians) to be executed. And you defend Islam and ask what homosexuality has to do with anything.
Not only are you a liar, you are an ignorant ding-a-ling.
Why should we respect you enough to even consider what you say?
I have a female name? are you kidding me? with a name like PHILLEP? WHAT SHOULD i ASSUME YOU ARE? MALE OR FEMALE? or some where in between? I could have said I was born a muslim… does h
that make you happier? so what Islam calls for the excution of homsexual. no kidding ick Tracey! did you figure this out on your own? what does that have to do with me? what is the difference between you and Jew haters? nothing! Jew haters blame every thing on the Jews and you like the anti semites and Jew haters assume that every muslim is a terrorist and homophobic….
17. miriam rove
Why the FLAMES? I too am confused about your web identity. But only because YOU brought it up.
And I don’t follow your logic.
Show how you make the following inference from Phillep’s(?) comment:
“…you like the anti semites and Jew haters assume that every muslim is a terrorist and homophobic….”
I don’t think I’ve ever heard anyone say that, exactly.
But if only one in a thousand muslims is seriously homophobic, (and has Shariah on his side to be judge, jury and executioner), that’s 1.5 million. Probably 10% are homophobic; I don’t know; that’s a pure guess. That would be 150 million Shariah zealot homophobes. Scary for the ‘target’ audience; and mind-boggling that homosexual organizations everywhere ‘embrace’ islam, and bash Israel (where they are safe). Some say that the former brown-nose the latter, but that sounds disgusting.
How many serious jihadists are there? One percent is a small number. Conservative? But that’s 15 million jihadists. 15 million too many!
Further, if only one in a million muslims is a terrorist, a real terrorist, not a wannabee, that’s still 1,500 loose cannons, or exploding nail bombs running wild, on our otherwise peaceful planet.
That’s 1,500 too many.
And more than all other religions put together.