Seven Reasons Why Corruption Reigns in Spain
Hardly a week goes by without news of another high-profile corruption scandal in Spain. Several theories seek to explain the phenomenon.
More than 85 percent of Spaniards believe corruption in Spain is “very widespread” or “fairly widespread,” according to a new opinion poll conducted by the Madrid-based Sociological Research Center (CIS), an agency that provides the Spanish government with polling data. Only 0.2 percent of those polled believe corruption is “not widespread” in Spain.
More surprising (or maybe not) is the poll’s finding that most Spaniards view their fellow countrymen as relatively ambivalent about the corruption in Spain. Of those polled, 41.5 percent say Spaniards are “fairly tolerant” and 20 percent say they are “very tolerant” of corruption in Spain. More than 50 percent of those surveyed say Spaniards “almost never” or “never” obey the law.
Sixty percent of Spaniards say corruption is just a “part of human nature” and more than one-third believe it is “part of Spanish culture.” More than 85 percent of Spaniards say corruption exists because the government allows it; only 9.3 percent believe citizens have a responsibility to fight against it.
The poll comes amid news of yet another high-profile corruption scandal in Spain. On July 1, Spanish police raided the offices of the Society of Authors and Publishers (SGAE), Spain’s leading collection agency for songwriters and composers, and arrested nine senior officials suspected of embezzling up to €400 million ($575 million) in royalties that should have been distributed to musicians and record companies.
One of the largest corruption scandals in Spanish history, the Caso Malaya, involves 95 municipal officials in southern Spain who are accused of taking more than €2 billion ($3 billion) in bribes in exchange for building permits and/or contracts to run municipal services in the glitzy resort town of Marbella. The case, which is truly mindboggling in scale and scope, has spawned dozens of other investigations into corruption on the Costa del Sol.
Another ongoing corruption scandal is the Caso Gürtel involving Francisco Correa (Correa means Belt in English or Gürtel in German), a businessman who paid millions in bribes (in the form of cash, luxury cars, designer clothing, Caribbean holidays, and lavish parties with prostitutes) to dozens of municipal officials and regional politicians, in exchange for building permits and contracts in Valencia, Madrid, Galicia and Castilla-León. Correa is suspected of accumulating a secret fortune worth at least €50 million ($70 million); he has not declared any income to the tax office since 1999.
The investigation into Correa and his network was launched by Spain’s so-called “Super-Judge” Baltasar Garzón, but he himself has since been fired for abuse of power and for failing to declare more than $200,000 in earnings from the Spanish tax authorities.
Other high-profile corruption cases in Spain abound: Caso Millet, involving the diversion of €35 million from the Palau de la Mùsica in Barcelona; Caso Palma Arena, involving 30 defendants accused of misappropriating tens of millions of euros linked to construction of a €100 million indoor sports stadium in Palma de Mallorca; Caso Pretoria, involving 20 defendants accused of receiving millions of euros in bribes in exchange for building permits in Catalonia.
Still other cases include: Caso Arona, Caso Baeza, Caso Can Domengue, Caso Castellón, Caso Ceclavín, Caso Ciudad Real, Caso de los EREs, Caso de Miguel, Caso El Rosario, Caso Faycán, Caso Granadilla, Caso Guisando, Caso Ibiza, Caso La Gomera, Caso Las Navas del Marqués, Caso Llucmajor, Caso Loja, Caso Martina Gelabert, Caso Mercasevilla, Caso Muxia, Caso Ocaña, Caso Ohanes, Caso Pájara, Caso Palma Arena, Caso Sevilla, Caso Salares, Caso Son Oms, Caso Sotohenar, Caso Torrejón de Ardoz, Caso Tudela de Duero, Caso Villanueva de Gómez, Caso Villanueva de la Cañada, Caso Vipasa, and Caso Zambrana.
Recent corruption-related police raids include: Operación Arcos, Operación Brisán, Operación Brugal, Operación Citur, Operación Costurero, Operación Harrag, Operación Molinos, Operación Orquesta, Operación Palmera, Operación Tequila, Operación Tótem, Operación Troya, and Operación Unión, among many others.
Overall, Spain’s Ministry of Justice is currently investigating more than 700 cases of high-level corruption involving politicians from both major parties in all of the country’s 48 provinces. This includes 264 cases involving Socialists, 200 involving Conservatives, and hundreds more involving smaller regional parties. (See here for a map of corruption in Spain according to political party.)
After it emerged that more than 100 Socialist and Conservative politicians were running for re-election in municipal elections in May 2011 who were simultaneously under investigation for corruption, the head of the Socialist Party flippantly declared that corrupt Socialists were less corrupt than corrupt Conservatives.
One essay summed it up: “Being a corrupt politician in Spain is the safest criminal job there is. It is much safer than robbing banks or stealing handbags from old ladies. This country has invented the most effective system of impunity that is known in the galaxy, based on the motto ‘and you are more corrupt.’ Each party takes the view that their corrupt politicians are less corrupt than those of other parties and for that reason their corruption is the most beneficial.”
Spain has dropped five positions in the annual Corruption Perceptions Index produced by the Berlin-based Transparency International. Spain ranked number 30 in 2010, down from number 25 in 2005. Bribery, money laundering, and tax fraud have cost Spain at least €4.2 billion ($6 billion) over the past ten years, according to calculations by the center-right El Mundo newspaper, which calculated the figure based on court records and investigations of just 28 of the biggest corruption cases.
Spanish newspapers have been chock full of articles reflecting on Spain’s propensity for corruption: “Corruption in Spain: A Grave Problem for the Loss of Foreign Investment“; “The Corruption Ballot“; “The Map of Socialist Shame in Extremadura“; “New Form of Corruption: Keep the Money of Fake Retirees“; and “Why is There so Much Corruption in Spain?“.
International media have also published stories on the phenomenon: “Why is Spain so Corrupt?“; “Scandal Sullies Spain’s Clean Energy“; “Spain Sees Endless Season for Political Scandal“; “Spain and the Rise of Eco-Corruption?“; “Corruption Widespread in Spanish Universities“; and “Corruption in Spain: Shady Deals in the Sun.”
From these analyses, it is possible to discern seven theories (structural, cultural, and/or historical) which try to explain the prevalence of corruption in Spain:
The “Opportunity” Theory: This structural theory posits that a decades-long construction boom created unprecedented opportunities for corruption in Spain. As local governments issued building permits and authorized changes in land use from rural to urban development, they created huge profits for property developers as well as for municipalities. Taking this theory one step further, local bureaucrats on fixed salaries were able to leverage their power vis-à-vis cash-rich property developers to demand bribes in exchange for approving and fast-tracking building permits.
The “Incentives” Theory: This structural theory posits that Spain’s notorious bureaucracy creates added incentives for corruption: the more red tape involved in doing business, the greater the likelihood that a bureaucrat will demand a bribe and/or the more incentive there is to pay for “short-cuts.” In other words: the bigger the government, the greater potential for abuse.
The “Transparency” Theory: This structural theory posits that the lack of transparency in Spanish government institutions and decision-making increases the likelihood for corruption because the chances of getting caught taking a bribe are relatively low. When combined with lax law enforcement and weak punishments, corruption becomes more commonplace.
The “Regionalism” Theory: This structural/historical theory posits that after the death of General Francisco Franco in 1975 and the end of his 40-year dictatorship, Spain’s fledgling democracy devolved considerable power back to the regions. In the post-Franco period, national parties have been highly dependent on coalitions with regional parties in order to govern. This has encouraged a certain “hands-off” policy of non-intervention by the central government in local/regional affairs. This in turn has cemented a system of clientelism into the fiber of regions like Andalucía and Extremadura, which have been ruled by the Socialist Party for more than three decades.
The “Allegiance” Theory: This cultural theory posits that in Spain and other southern European countries where corruption is rife, people often look after the immediate and extended family before the greater good of society as a whole. This “me first” attitude incentivizes corruption at the most basic level of social organization, whether it be family, village, town, city, province, and/or region.
The “Religion” Theory: This cultural theory posits that as a works-based religion, Roman Catholicism facilitates corruption in countries (like Spain) where it dominates because it is easy to sin and be forgiven. According to this theory, the act of confession to a priest and doing penance (simply reciting a mantra of Hail Mary’s) enables wrongdoers to balance their sins with good deeds. This is in contrast to Protestant theology, where sinners are held directly accountable to God Himself. Many analysts also point to a connection between Roman Catholicism and clientelism in Spain.
The “Revenge” Theory: This cultural/historical theory posits that corruption is a habit that was revived during the Franco dictatorship when thwarting the state was an act of resistance. Others say that after Franco died, Spain entered into a period of 14 years (1982-1996) of uninterrupted socialism when people took “revenge” against the dictatorship by “reclaiming” what was “stolen” from them.
Which theory is best? Most observers of Spanish politics would probably agree that corruption in the country can be best explained by a combination of all the theories, although all the money generated by the construction boom created perfect conditions for spiralling corruption.
The big unanswered question is: With Spain on the brink of financial collapse, how much longer will Spaniards tolerate the endemic corruption that is such a huge drain on the national economy?
Good article again.
Personally I would plump for the “Allegiance” theory.
Youre 100% right Ed. James Michener’s Carribbean includes a section describing Spanish Colonial corruption in Latin America based on the “family first, then the king” rational. The Spaniards havent changed. The worst thing about it isnt that they contnue to steal from themselves, which is their own fault, but this attitude infected Latin American elites, who still practice the same values. Colombia has tried to get a handle on this mentality for at least ten years, with some success but exposure of high level corruption is still a daily news event. In Venezuela, Chavez controls the press so no one hears about it, but levels of corruption and crime there have probably reached historic highs. Caracas is now the most dangerous city in LA. The joke is of you are robbed, dont call the police because theyll rob you again.
Wow. Spain is almost to Chicago levels of corruption.
Nope. Not even close.
Unlike Chicago, those court cases and media attention in Spain mean that enough people are concerned about the corruption to try to roll it back to some degree.
That said, human nature being what it is, corruption can never be eliminated entirely from Spain or from anywhere else. And too much government power at any level always breeds corruption.
Don’t forget the cultural factor. Spain has always been a culture with a rigidly-stratified society, practically a “caste” system, in which who your ancestors are is at least as important as who you are. As such, many positions of power and influence become de facto hereditary, whether they are supposed to be or not.
In such a culture, anyone trying to “get ahead” is viewed with grave suspicion by those who have already “arrived”. Which means rising in the world is, if not out of the question, at least extremely difficult. Unless, of course, one has a powerful patron’. (Note that that is a Spanish word, itself.)
And such powerful patrons will demand tribute in return for their patronage. Ranging from obedience, to favors, to bribes. The Spanish term “la mordida” (“the bite”) is commonly used to describe the latter, and has been for the last several centuries.
Incidentally, when the Spanish conquistadors came to the Americas, they brought their caste-like, stratified culture with them. Added to the existing rigidly-stratified (and brutal) Inca/Mayan/Aztec cultures, it in no small way accounts for the parlous state of South and Central America today.
Those with power exploit those without- and see nothing wrong with doing so. They just think we “Norteamericanos” are crazy and bigoted for not approving of their ways.
clear ether
eon
You omit the nationalistic theory where corrupt politicains get away by fanning nationalism (“I am not corrupt, it is a sinister plot of MadriT”, Madrit not a typo), are able to divert lots of money by pumping thousands of millions into nationalistic organisations or press, along with going to such extermes as creating “embassies” in foreign countries (except that since thety are not recognized their only function is to siphon millions kinto adequete pocket”) or, like with leonese, artificially recreate languages who were long dead by the time America was discovered.
“The big unanswered question is: With Spain on the brink of financial collapse, how much longer will Spaniards tolerate the endemic corruption that is such a huge drain on the national economy?”
At this point it doesn’t really matter anymore. With 20% unemployment, a stagnant economy, high taxes, and a gigantic social-welfare system, it’s only a matter of time before Spain goes bust, just like Greece, Portugal, Italy, and Ireland. But once it goes, so will the entire European Union. Italy may just beat it to total collapse, but that’s not saying much. Years and years of corruption and socialism has brought Spain to where it is today, an economic basket case. It’s only a question of when, and not if, Spain’s economy is going to go bankrupt.
Why would anyone be surprised at this? The bureaucrats put in the rules and regulations and then profit by selling their services to bypass said rules and regulations. This happens all the time with no downside to the bureaucrats who sell this “service”. Look at the US. Why would the politicians spend enormous sums of money to get elected to a job that pays 150K a year?
Hey, we have a former Chicago politician as president.
Enough said.
OTOH, I doubt their Treasury Secretary got his job AFTER he was caught cheating on his taxes.
I see corruption as just another lifestyle choice. Anyone that judges my corruption is guilty of a hate crime.
Spain has three strikes against it.
First, they are correct – this IS human nature.
Second, yep, the religion theory. Roman Catholicism breeds corruption wherever it holds sway. Check Latin America for another example. See also the assassination of Abraham Lincoln for another. (All conspirators were known to be Catholics. The list is endless.
Third, Marxism breeds corruption. Yes, yes, I know, I know, they are socialists, not Marxists. Yada yada yada. It’s the same thing with different window dressing. Like identical tract homes with different paint jobs.
Yes, it’s a combination of all of the theories mentioned, but these three are the foundation blocks.
Having worked in Spain and with friends there, I can tell you that things operate differently. The Spanish government frequently enacts new laws that make previously legitimate activities illegal, it makes the law retroactive. In other words, when you committed the act it was perfect;y legal but you can be arrested for it now anyway. The only defense is to amass large sums of money so that when the Feds come knocking you have the resources to defend yourself. And in many cases the only way to defend yourself is a bribe.
It seems so easy to criticize other governments like Afghanistan and Spain for their corruption while turning a blind eye on our own. Corruption runs rampant in our country from the federal level right down to local government. Lets clean up ours before we worry about others. Our economy is in terrible shape just like these other countries due to this same corruption.
The whole democratic party runs on government money.
“this IS human nature”
Yes Mark, spot on. This is what the left will never understand. They believe that THEY can change Human Nature either through coercion or with an iron fist to create Utopia. Currenlty it is through corrupion, cronyism, and coercion. They may try to use the iron fist, but I sort of doubt it as there are 4 million NRA members who may not let them unless they can get the guns out of their ‘cold dead hands’. In the end I don’t think the left will do it with arms, but by wearing the week minded useful idiots down with with goodies and coercion. They will never give up or go away, so stand guard.
I don’t know about Catholics being the cause, but I do know that Most of the “Latin” countries in Europe are welfare states and some like Spain, Portugal, Italy for example have huge underground economies. The difference between European Latins and American are that in Latin America there is no state welfare over here (Chavez, heh,heh,heh) and with few exceptions (maybe Chili) the corruptoin is rife from top to bottom hence 500,000 latins cross over to the U.S. every year to soak up the welfare and send their checks home.
Mexico is not a poor country in land or resources, but it is corrupt beyond our wildest imagination.
The Spanish disease is not Syphilis but social particularism;
There is no feeling of community to restrain one group from
taking whatever it can from ‘Those Other People’.
Oppressive taxes and regulation greatly increases the likelihood of corruption.
hhhhmmmmmmmm….int…er…es…ting. You may have something there my dear Wigglesworth.
“…he has not declared any income to the tax office since 1999.”
There are cabinet posts and congressional seats waiting for just such a person.
REASON 8:
Arabs owned Spain for 800 years before 1492. Lack of responsibility and accountability, and therefore corruption, are embedded in the culture and the language.
yes I agree with that. In fact that is partly true of all countries in southern Europe, extending into France as well. The dead hand of Islam clearly corrupted these countries leading to selfishness and almost an entire absence of a civic space, redolent of all of North Africa and the middle east.
For anyone planning to visit Spain take note of the fact that there is no law against pickpocketing if the amount is less than about $300. The police may stop the thirf but turn him loose when the abused is gone. Be cautious, all the time, and in any place.
You could change Spain to CALIFORNIA OR ILLINOIS and it would be just as accurate
I vote for the revenge factor. What happens to the soul of a country whose leaders cheat? Isn’t Europe disarmed for the most part? So in essence what you have is serfdoms run by corrupt governments. Therefore crime bosses and drug lords have become the ultimate entrepreneurs. They enjoy the underground economy where the government doesn’t have the right to steal their earnings like they do from the rest of us.
Check out http://www.libertysoup.org/Home.html for tools to INSIST on cuttiing, capping and balancing the federal budget.
Governments are only as corrupt as we allow them to be. ( Wasn’t that a title from a recent PJ or TH commentary)
Spain .The most corrupt country in Europe . The Spanish people are all corrupt , and will grin in your face whilst slitting your throat .AVOID SPAIN .