Get PJ Media on your Apple

Preserve an Ecosystem, or Preserve an EPA Rule?

Prescribed fires are necessary to preserve a prairie ecosystem, but the smoke causes regulatory problems for cities downwind. It's the EPA versus nature.

by
Patrick Richardson

Bio

May 14, 2010 - 12:00 am
<- Prev  Page 2 of 2   View as Single Page

The problem, so far as EPA is concerned, is the smoke from these fires can travel for hundreds of miles and cause cities as far away as St. Louis to fail clean air act standards — particularly in years where the burning season is condensed because of factors such as rain and wind. This has happened three times in this century: 2003, 2006, and again this year. Wichita, Kansas City, and St. Louis have all been affected at various times.

Moran said the EPA has threatened these cities with fines if they don’t meet the standards, which through no fault of their own they haven’t met.

According to Moran, at this point the fines have not been levied but the threat is there. Moreover, if they don’t get the impossible plan they’re asking for, the EPA may ban the burning altogether, and that’s the fear of both Moran and the ranchers who depend on the area for their livelihood.

Should the prescribed burns end, the tall-grass prairie would disappear within a generation:

“That would destroy something that is a pretty special place,” Moran said.

Mark Smith, president of the Kansas Livestock Association, agreed:

We have to have that tool to keep one of the last great natural areas in the world natural.

Enter Moran’s legislation, which would simply exempt cities from the Clean Air Act so long as they can show the violation was due to smoke from the Flint Hills. Moran said all he would like to see is a little common sense, as environmental regulations are currently in danger of … damaging the environment.

It particularly stands out because it’s the support of an environmentally sound practice that is being attacked.

Moran is hoping to attract cosponsors for his bill. Kansas Rep. Lynn Jenkins has already signed on, and he expects the rest of the Kansas delegation probably will and thinks Oklahoma will as well.

He thinks it’s possible to get the bill passed, but acknowledges it will be an uphill fight with the current administration and Congress — and if it does pass, it will probably have to be folded into larger legislation which may cause people to “holdeth aside the hem of the garment” in order to pass it:

“It’s very hard to get anything perceived as dangerous to the environment through this Congress,” he said. “One would hope common sense would prevail.”

One would hope.

Please contact your representatives and ask them to support Moran’s bill, H.R.5118. This is the last place in the world of it’s kind, and shortsighted regulations threaten the destruction of a beautiful area and unique lifestyle.

<- Prev  Page 2 of 2   View as Single Page
Patrick Richardson has been a journalist for almost 15 years and an inveterate geek all his life. He blogs regularly at www.otherwheregazette.com, which aims to be like another SF magazine, just not so serious.
Click here to view the 16 legacy comments

Comments are closed.