Nothing Surprising in Leaked Copenhagen Draft Agreement (Updated)
Update
Imagine if a Bush administration official had said this:
“Asked about arguments by diplomats and some protesters that the United States should provide hundreds of billions of dollars in aid to developing nations as reparations, Mr. Stern, the special envoy for climate change, bluntly fired back at a news conference. ‘I actually completely reject the notion of a debt or reparations or anything of the like,’ he said. ‘For most of the 200 years since the Industrial Revolution, people were blissfully ignorant of the fact that emissions caused a greenhouse effect. It’s a relatively recent phenomenon.’”
In truth, Arrhenius famously posited the greenhouse effect in 1896. The Industrial Revolution is generally accepted as having begun in or about 1850. The greenhouse effect is not the same as the modern left’s claim that economic activity must be held in check because Man’s contribution is creating dangerous climate change. But the ignorance is fairly revealing: it’s not about the climate or the science to these people.
Do I need to tell you that the New York Times’ highly political science reporter Andrew Revkin did not blink at this? The paper has not always been so forgiving of misunderstandings of the matter by political officials.
————————————-
If there is something surprising in the leaked draft text developed by the U.S., UK, Denmark, and (maybe) others that transfers the management of Kyoto II’s billions to the World Bank, I haven’t seen it. This Guardian story cites outraged activists and hangers-on in Copenhagen over the contents.
After reading the text, I have to conclude that this is either a leak intended to gain traction for phonied-up outrage to spin things here as somehow headed in a reasonable direction, or else it is the hysterics of an exceedingly paranoid global warming establishment fearful of anything it didn’t actually have a hand in drafting.
Anyway, here’s my read of things.
Any possible window dressing of moving management from the UN to the World Bank is not actually declared or apparent anywhere in the document’s text. Article 22 makes clear that a “Climate Fund be established as an operating entity of” a mechanism under the existing “Rio” treaty framework, ratified by the U.S. and which Kyoto amended and implemented.
The same corrupt Mother Ship, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), implements and monitors funding. The document asserts that additional revenues will come from aviation and shipping (read: international commerce, airline, and cruise ship) taxes. This is hardly change we can believe in.
Once ratified, these finance decisions will be implemented by consensus and, failing that, a two-thirds vote, of which the U.S. has an equal voice with our peers from Andorra to Zimbabwe. Even if there were some grounds in this document that would result in a claim that someone was trying to remove financing from the UN to a separate entity, it should be viewed like the current effort to claim that a non-profit entity would manage what is otherwise called the “public option” in the health care takeover. Clearly the claim is made to avoid the notion that it is government-run insurance.
It would be purely optics, and the scheme still quacks, flies, and does everything else like the old duck. The principal outrage from the welfare states clinging to Kyoto II as a revenue stream is that there is some inkling that they might actually have to do something under what this draft text envisions. Not hardly.
The motivations of this global energy rationing scheme, administered through some supranational body or otherwise international framework, have always been at minimum two-fold: get the U.S. in check and keep the poor from getting Western-style rich. This document reflects both of those desires.
It caps our economic activity, barring unforeseen developments in energy technology so staggering as to be truly “breakthrough,” keeping the U.S. handcuffed economically while picking our pockets and keeping the poor world poor as part of the deal.
This is good news.
Any Senator voting for this will be job hunting after the next election he stands for. Bureaucrats often overestimate their power. A current example would be the Department of State claiming that LOST is in force, even though the Senate hasn’t ratified it. They can claim all they want, the US Navy, which would have to enforce LOST, just ignores them. That means everyone else ignores them also, since there can be no law without enforcement. That is a fact that most law makers and bureaucrats forget.
Hopefully, this outrageous violation of the UN Charter by the UN will give impetus to getting the USA out of the UN and the UN out of the USA. That way, we could create a new international body for nations that practice consensual government. Cut off the Despots and tyrants and let them wither on the vine. Or if that is too radical for most, change the rules at the UN so that UN Employees are drawn from the private sector for 4 year terms of employment. Keeping the turn over high would cut down on graft and corruption as well as making it harder for the UN to plan power grabs such as Kyoto II. Not as good as sending the UN the way of the League of Nations, but better then hiding our heads in the sand and pretending nothing is wrong.
To paraphrase Obama after the near fatal collapse of our economy due to CRA, Jimmy Carter, liberal “wealthy” Democrat senators, and others, “we cannot continue with an economic system that allows drastic swings, up or down.” No, Obama and his administration along with a gathering of unrealistic and ignorant leftists have purposely undertaken the self appointed task of reshaping America and the world. Using Alinsky methodology and tactics, they have seized upon an unnatural cycle of economic upheaval as a direct result of social engineering and unbridled greed emanating from Wall Street during a cycle of opportunistic wealth gains to plant the seeds of radical changes without having to fire one single shot in anger.
The AGW conference in Copenhagen is one of the major pieces of the puzzle to fall in place along with TARP, Stimulus I, and health care. As each program moves its way through the process, the entrapment of a people into a controlling regime of socialism tightens its grip on us.
We will have to pay for medical care for everyone who lives in America, legal or not, employed or not, responsible or not. All from our tax dollars that shrink in value each day. As the banks move through the briar patch of TARP regulation and requirements, they withhold needed credit and loans to legitimate business opportunities and squelch the development of smaller entrepreneurs whose growth has been stagnated. No new tax revenues are being generated by small business growth but we are expected to shoulder new burdens, one after another until the back of non-government controlled America is broken and the only medical assistance available is the government, run by Obama, liberals, socialists, and in general, America apologists. Those who believe America is the root cause of the world’s problems.
The AGW conference will assist in completing the cycle of destruction and if it is a success in terms of the attendees, we will see a set of regulations enacted by the EPA who now has a free hand in determining CO2 levels and other greenhouse gases without having to answer to anyone. Included in this scenario is the added financial burden that will be placed on developed countries, especially America, to send billions to a conglomeration of large and small third world countries to do with as they please. We will voluntarily hand over our wealth, competitive edge and all intellectual properties developed under the “evil” capitalist economic system that has served this country so well. That is except for the priviledged ones who kneel at the altars of Obama, Al Gore, and the Kennedy family.
Stimulus I, Health Care, and AGW are just three in a long list of the coming changes that will be enacted within the next few months if we are not diligent and get involved to stop this runaway train of “domestic nation building”. Obama and his crew view America as a nation that does need to be rebuilt from the ground up. So far, they have succeeded in more destruction than imaginable so they can provide fertile ground to start a new society and government. We already have an unprecedented number of czars who have an extraordinary amount of power without running for an elected office or having to go through a vetting system of elected representatives.
AGW in Copenhagen is another railcar in the runaway train of destruction and incompetence so prevalent in this administration. No wonder the polls are showing George W. Bush almost even with Obama in one year. Unfortunately, for the next few months, all we can do is continue to make as much noise as we can.
I believe North Korea with no lights at night and its starving citizens getting shorter each generation is probably the closest thing to a modern carbon neutral nation state we have. I’m sure its per capita carbon consumption is less than the third world average, and South Korea is a carbon consuming pig by comparison. Instead of the UN and its typical oil for food frauds, perhaps we should encourage more covert nuclear proliferation among rogue states to achieve a reduction in the world’s per capita carbon levels? At least their elites get to be technologically sophisticated while the masses starve for their versions of the “dear one.” And on schedule the rich and wealthy states get to pay yearly extortion to keep those rogues from building too many bombs. The same dynamic is currently working with the Palestinians, but on a less technological “kamikazi” level, where the extorted West gets to fund the “peace process” as reparations for the wrongs of occidental colonialism. It could work, and much more efficiently than cap and trade.
Let’s see if I understand this correctly. First money is taken from the “rich” energy consuming nations with or without the consent of their citizenry. The funds are then “managed” by the U.N. ( or the World bank) whose zealous administrators take a 10 to 15% cut. Whats left is sent out tho the poor nations including soe well known kleptocracies. About half the funds are eaten up in more “administration” and a whole lot ends up in numbered Swiss bank accounts as a retirement fund for certain beloved leaders. The funds are now judged as insufficient for the task of levelling the climate change playing field so we restart at the beginning.
The whole thing in Copenhagne is about control, not climate~
4- right.
Check out the Copenhagen Document leaks, this knowledge may save your life! Do what you can with your Government Reps in your country to have these infringements on your life eliminated! You will literally be fighting for your and your family’s existence, Click the videos below:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dAqqAnUxACY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94KH-WMZuw0
Request that PM Harper doesn’t sign the Copenhagen Treaty, thereby causing Canadians to lose their Sovereignty and Freedom, email the PM at: pm@pm.gc.ca
Sign the petition to protest the Inaccurate Science measurements that are being used to base the Copenhagen Treaty off of: http://www.gopetition.com/online/32485.html