News
Directly To
Your Inbox
Follow PJ Media

More D.C. Voucher Shenanigans

School vouchers are losing because they’re winning.

by
Greg Forster

Bio

April 18, 2009 - 12:00 am
Page 1 of 2  Next ->   View as Single Page

Ever since the latest scandal at the U.S. Department of Education broke earlier this month, the department has been saying one thing and doing another. But even if the department’s double talk allows voucher opponents to prevail, the double talk itself only proves that their days in power are numbered.

The original scandal was that the department kept secret vital information showing the D.C. Opportunity Scholarship Program improves academic outcomes while Congress took a crucial vote on its future. When the department finally had to release the good news about vouchers, it tried to bury the facts under spin and obfuscation. And when that failed to keep the story out of the papers, it accused the Wall Street Journal of lying about how it withheld vital information from Congress. But an investigation quickly proved that it wasn’t the Journal who was lying.

Now, the plot has thickened — and so has the duplicity. With no legal basis for doing so, the department has preemptively declared the program dead by forbidding it to accept applications for the fall.

Never mind that Congress hasn’t ended the program — it voted to make next year’s funding conditional on later votes of approval from itself and the D.C. Council. By forbidding anyone to apply for vouchers next year, with no legal basis for doing so since the program has not been ended by Congress, the department ensures that the program will end regardless of what Congress decides.

Never mind the law; the U.S. Department of Education does what it pleases. But then, voucher opponents have never been particularly scrupulous about their methods.

Adding insult to injury, the department has pretended that it’s not killing the program even while killing it. The department sent voucher families a weasel-worded letter designed to create the impression that it’s working to help save the voucher students even as it drives the knife into their backs. And the education secretary told the Chicago Tribune that he supposedly hasn’t ruled out supporting the program, almost exactly at the same time his department was unilaterally shutting the program down.

PJ Media appreciates your comments that abide by the following guidelines:

1. Avoid profanities or foul language unless it is contained in a necessary quote or is relevant to the comment.

2. Stay on topic.

3. Disagree, but avoid ad hominem attacks.

4. Threats are treated seriously and reported to law enforcement.

5. Spam and advertising are not permitted in the comments area.

These guidelines are very general and cannot cover every possible situation. Please don't assume that PJ Media management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment. We reserve the right to filter or delete comments or to deny posting privileges entirely at our discretion. Please note that comments are reviewed by the editorial staff and may not be posted immediately. If you feel your comment was filtered inappropriately, please email us at story@pjmedia.com.

12 Comments, 12 Threads

  1. 1. Delia

    Beck did a whole segment today on his show on Fox News about this very subject.

    The hypocrisy of the Zero administration is so blatant it makes MY eyes bleed!

    HOME SCHOOL, PEOPLE! If you have the wherewithal, do it. You can’t do any worse than these libtard teachers with their propaganda brain-washed teachings of history et al.

    Parents who have illiterate children should stop having children. The public school system is a joke. Rely on THEM to teach your child and you’re a lazy parent. Stop poppin’ out kids if you don’t want to teach your child and help them learn what the inept, libtard teachers don’t teach to children.

    Yes, there are SOME good teachers out there but it’s far and few between. The brain-washing begins in Kindergarten… Good luck trying to undo that sh*t.

  2. 2. pedro

    I can imagine what Michelle Rhee is thinking!

  3. 3. Nosinin

    What a surprise, on the air touting one thing while systematically shredding the same thing, along with our constitution.

  4. 4. William

    Dock teachers pay when they go on strike, the teacher’s unions would collapse.

  5. 5. kywrite

    My dream scenario: Barack’s cute little girls come to him, asking why their little friends who depend on the voucher program won’t be able to come back to their school next year.

  6. 6. Max

    I certainly hope that vouchers win out in the long run, and I think that they might for the same reasons that this post mentions. It’s too bad, though, that we’re going to have to wait at least 4 years for a president with enough of a spine to stand up to the unions; being young and idealistic, I used to think there might be a sliver of a chance that Obama was genuinely more interested in education reform- “change”- than collecting a decent chunk of change from the unions for Obama 2012. Apparently I was wrong.

  7. 7. Rubicon

    There is an entrenched bureaucracy within the education establishment. Part of it is the union that has demanded more & more money “for the kids” while they have only made things worse. Grades are down in public schools, kids are dropping out wholesale. Its just a factory system designed to produce community activist types for social change, while they can do not actual work & create anything but havoc.
    The system protects itself. Even when a really bad educator is uncovered publicly, they cover for them & arrange for them to be placed elsewhere.
    Now, finally, progress is being made exposing the liars for who & what they are. The DOE truly messed up on this one since most already knew vouchers were working in DC where it truly benefits poor kids. But, the union & establishment did not care about that. They want their way, more power over all, and of course, much more money to produce even more failures. Average kids lose out & never get to exploit their potential, while privileged kids w/ contacts get some education. Even that is tainted by the crowd promoting only social change, while doing little for those they say they are helping.
    Despite an almost total national media blackout, the word is out that the Education Department fixed the results & hid real results.
    Too many now know what they did & too many now know why they did it.
    The battle “might” be lost in DC for now…. but the war is on its way to being won as we force educators to return to education or get out of the business for those truly interested in educating our futures.

  8. 8. Delia

    5. kywrite,

    You are so mean. That’s just WRONG. Whoops. I let out a giggle. he-he :lol:

  9. 9. ked5

    1 Delia

    the propagandizing begins in pre-school. There are so many homeschool supplies out there now, the opportunities will fit almost any family’s circumstances.

    Many of the arguments the teachers unions and their supporters use against homeschooling is the socilaizaition of children. The homeschoolers I know do so becasue they DON’T want the socialization from the public school system.

  10. 10. ked5

    #5

    those poor little girls aren’t allowed to play with little girls who go to public school – and heaven forbid they be allowed to play with little girls in a voucher program. Nothing but children of the elites are good enough for them, because that’s who they have for parents.

  11. 11. therealist

    The school voucher program study has the potential to “go wide” and change everything – this is hard evidence that children in DC would get a far better education for half as much money. Who doesn’t want a better education for their children. It would even win support of people who already put their kids in private school as it would save them money.

    If a conservative revolt does happen (note for Neopolitano: a *political* revolt) I believe it will happen around two issues: school vouchers and illegal immigration. Both are completely indefensible policies that have the most terrible effects on the lowest income Americans (of any race) and help keep them trapped in the most miserable conditions. Illegal immigration is off-topic here, but the argument is simply that it imports crime and poverty that hits the lower income segment the most (as that’s where illegal aliens live and compete for jobs with). In both of these issues lower income individuals are clear voting for their own misery – and they know it.

  12. 12. Aaron Byrnes

    It is time for these voucher parents to have their own version of a Tea Party?

Leave a Reply

Click here to subscribe to the Daily Digest, to stay up to date with the latest at PJ Media. (You will be sent an email asking you to verify your email address. If you have previously subscribed, no verification email will be sent.)