News
Directly To
Your Inbox
Follow PJ Media

Hillary Stumbles, Rudy And Fred Struggle

Hillary Clinton's status as clear Democratic frontrunner is beginning to fade, as she heads into a dead heat in Iowa and PJM prognosticator William Bradley looks ahead to a week where she'll gamble on restoring her status in a Las Vegas debate. On the Republican side, the problem isn't what Rudy Giuliani and Fred Thompson have done - but what their friends Bernie Kerik and Philip Martin have been up to and how the candidates deal with it.

by
Bill Bradley

Bio

November 12, 2007 - 1:00 am

The week ahead in presidential politics sees the Democrats heading west to roll the dice in another debate, this time in Las Vegas. On the Republican side, Rudy Giuliani and Fred Thompson are dealing with scandals surrounding close political associates, giving Mitt Romney, who already leads in early states, an edge, and John McCain fresh ammo to get back in the race.

Meanwhile on this Veterans Day weekend — with this presidential race in which only McCain among the top tier candidates in either party is a vet — crises in politico-military affairs continue to bubble dangerously in Pakistan, Iran, Turkey, and Iraq, with the prices of oil and gold held aloft by huge risk premiums. Though the Turkish situation has calmed some, if for no other reason than the weather, which increasingly makes a large-scale Turkish military incursion into northern Iraq to subdue Kurdish separatist guerillas using it as safe haven a less likely prospect.

As we headed into Veterans Day weekend, there were some signs that Hillary Clinton’s supposedly inevitable, front-running campaign was starting to fade.
Despite the repeated intervention of her popular husband, former President Bill Clinton, she’s back into a dead heat in Iowa. Now her trendline in New Hampshire, which she’s always viewed as her firewall against a possible loss in Iowa, appears to be heading down.

Clearly her performance in the last debate, week before last in Philadelphia, which was actually pretty strong till her gaffe at the end on drivers license for illegal immigrants, has changed the dynamics.

Actually, her performance in the debate a month before that was problematic for her as well, as I wrote at the time. It showcased a pattern of slipping questions and a classic frontrunner smugness.

It was only because her campaign so cleverly spun the third quarter fundraising results – misleading people, including me, into thinking she had done much less well than she had – that the problems exposed in that debate performance did not establish a new narrative for the campaign.

After first incongruously seeking to recoup from last week’s debate by complaining that the men were ganging up on her, Clinton is now saying she’s fine with all that. But she doesn’t seem very convincing.

The truth is that her opponents weren’t her problem in the Philadelphia debate. She created her own problems, largely in how she handled questions from the aggressive Tim Russert. While John Edwards did the best, he didn’t cause many problems for her. Nor did Barack Obama, who was definitely off his game.
It was actually Chris Dodd who forcefully objected to Clinton’s apparently changing views on the drivers license question. Only then did Edwards make his move.

Since then, they’ve both made major moves on Clinton. And Obama, by most assessments, scored very well at this past weekend’s Jefferson-Jackson dinner in Des Moines, Iowa, which featured speeches by all the candidates except for Dennis Kucinich and Mike Gravel, who have no campaigns to speak of in the first-in-the-nation contest.

One good thing going for Hillary in Thursday night’s debate in Vegas is that it’s being cablecast by CNN. Tim Russert won’t be there, since he’s an NBC guy. The Clintons usually do well on CNN, so this time Obama and Edwards may have to make their own luck.

But it seems they already are. In addition to Iowa being very much in play for either an Obama or an Edwards victory, Hillary is coming back to earth in New Hampshire.

The Granite State has always been her firewall against an Iowa loss. After being in a very tight race with Obama earlier this year, she had opened up a big lead there. Now that lead has been cut in half, to about 10 points, in two recent polls. That’s a lot of movement in a short period of time. But that’s what can happen in primaries, when voters are focused in.

The national numbers haven’t shown that sort of movement, though Hillary is down several points. But most voters still aren’t paying much attention. That will change dramatically as each contest gets closer for each state’s voters.

Meanwhile, Mitt Romney is picking up the pace of his advertising in early states such as Iowa and New Hampshire to extend this edge there, while John McCain takes aim at Giuliani and, to a lesser extent, Thompson, for their travails with close associates caught up in scandal.

Campaigning at the end of last week in Nevada, Rudy Giuliani called the indictment of his longtime friend and close associate, ex-New York Police Commissioner Bernie Kerik, on multiple federal corruption charges, “very serious and very sad.” Kerik was pushed successfully by Giuliani for appointment by President Bush to be the US secretary of homeland security. Then charges emerged of Kerik’s longtime ties to Mafia figures, his use of a luxury apartment donated for 9/11 rescue workers as “love shack” with a prominent conservative publisher, his employment of an illegal nanny, and on and on. His appointment to the Bush Cabinet was rescinded before the Senate could vote him down.

This is a deeply serious problem for Giuliani’s candidacy, since he is the one who elevated Kerik, a New York cop when he met him, first to the position of the mayor’s driver and bodyguard, then to the posts of New York corrections commissioner and New York police commissioner. Those two posts placed Kerik, respectively, in charge of New York’s extensive jail system and of the New York Police Department. After Giuliani left office following his star turn on 9/11, Kerik became his business partner in Giuliani’s highly lucrative consulting empire.

Fred Thompson’s old friend Philip Martin, with a couple of convictions for drug dealing in his past, has resigned from Thompson’s presidential campaign, in which he served as one of four founding finance chairmen. Thompson will no longer fly around on Martin’s plane, as he’s done throughout the year. In addition to his drug dealer past, Thompson’s old friend was trailed from state to state by a string of lawsuits by unhappy investors and business associates, as well as massive tax liens.

McCain is showing some movement in New Hampshire, which he won in 2000 over George W. Bush. But it won’t be easy for the one-time frontrunner for 2008 to resurrect his campaign again, after seeing it hammered first among independents and moderates for his pro-Iraq War stance, then by conservatives for his co-sponsorship of the failed immigration bill.

As for Romney, Giuliani and Thompson’s troubles come at a good time for him. He has strong leads in Iowa — where Mike Huckabee has supplanted the top tier candidates as the current runner-up — and New Hampshire. While Giuliani out-raised him in the third quarter, Romney is super-rich and can easily match whatever he raises. But he has a problem, too, beyond having embraced much more socially liberal positions in past campaigns than he is in this one. And that’s his religion, Mormonism, which polling shows to be a serious problem for many Christian Republicans.

I’m told he’s thinking of addressing the issue head-on, as John F. Kennedy did with his Catholicism in 1960. But others in the campaign are wary, worried that it will draw further attention.

PJ Media appreciates your comments that abide by the following guidelines:

1. Avoid profanities or foul language unless it is contained in a necessary quote or is relevant to the comment.

2. Stay on topic.

3. Disagree, but avoid ad hominem attacks.

4. Threats are treated seriously and reported to law enforcement.

5. Spam and advertising are not permitted in the comments area.

These guidelines are very general and cannot cover every possible situation. Please don't assume that PJ Media management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment. We reserve the right to filter or delete comments or to deny posting privileges entirely at our discretion. Please note that comments are reviewed by the editorial staff and may not be posted immediately. If you feel your comment was filtered inappropriately, please email us at story@pjmedia.com.

9 Comments, 9 Threads

  1. 1. Bot

    The Church of Jesus Christ (LDS) is often accused by Evangelical pastors of not believing in Christ and, therefore, not being a Christian religion. This article http://mormonsarechristian.blogspot.com/ helps to clarify such misconceptions by examining early Christianity’s comprehension of baptism, the Godhead, the deity of Jesus Christ and His Atonement.

    The Church of Jesus Christ (LDS) adheres more closely to First Century Christianity and the New Testament than any other denomination. Harper’s Bible Dictionary entry on the Trinity says “the formal doctrine of the Trinity as it was defined by the great church councils of the fourth and fifth centuries is not to be found in the New Testament.”

    Perhaps the reason the pastors denigrate the Church of Jesus Christ (LDS) is to protect their flock (and their livelihood). It is encouraging that Paul Weyrich, Wayne Grudem and Bob Jones III, (along with Jay Sekulow and Mark DeMoss) have rejected bigotry and now support

  2. “which was actually pretty strong till her gaffe at the end on drivers license for illegal immigrants”

    This was not really a gaffe. Hillary Clinton was doomed the very moment the question was asked. She is a Democrat and therefore was placed in a no-win situation. Only a Republican candidate can hit this one out of the ballpark. The odds are fairly decent that future historians will point to this incident as the beginning of the end regarding the Democrats chances in the 2008 elections.

  3. Bill Bradley: “Thompson will no longer fly around on Martin’s plane, as he’s done throughout the year. In addition to his drug dealer past, Thompson’s old friend was trailed from state to state by a string of lawsuits by unhappy investors and business associates, as well as massive tax liens.”

    As of September 1st the practice of receiving discounted travel as a form of donation was ended so your information is, to say the least, inaccurate.
    As far as Martin’s past is concerned he served whatever penalty was handed down over ten years before he even met Fred. Fifteen years after that for a total of Twenty-Five years in Martin’s past do you sit here and demand that Fred should somehow know what a typical background check would not uncover??…They only go back ten years! As far as civil suits, which successful businessman in this country has NOT been sued at one time or another for any host of reasons??

    This is nothing more than political Spinswaying Bill and you must know it!

  4. Bill, you really do need to included dates for scandals — and yes, anything over 10 years old is a LOT LESS important.

    Still, Huckabee is probably the man. A pro-life “compassionate conservative”, wanting to win in Iraq.

    All Dems are going to be facing the illegal immigration issues.

  5. 5. newton

    It’s too early to tell for me!

  6. “All Dems are going to be facing the illegal immigration issues.”

    This is because the Democrats have long propagandized that anyone who say ever says no to the demands of the illegal immigrants is a disgusting racist scum bag. Many of their own party, however, do not embrace this extremist position including numerous minorities. Alas, when you live by never endingly employing the race card—you can also die from it. The Democrats are in a no win situation. The far less politically correct Republicans should run with this issue. It may well help them not only to recapture the White House, but also both houses of Congress.

  7. 7. John

    Thought your readers might be interested in this interactive relationship map we made of the 2008 presidential frontrunners…

    http://www.muckety.com/2008-presidential-campaign-frontrunners/A1E246446B91A1C2A67A6F65BE25E319.map?big=true&autoGroup=7,8

  8. 8. Frank

    Ron Paul is the man for President and the future of the country. I would not trust any of these people with the future of my children. They are all owned by special interest groups that are not the interest of the people of this country.

    Paul accepts no benefits like the fat pension plan for congressman and understands the critical path that outsources of jobs has on the future of the American work force.

    No thanks to the GOP for our nation at war and DNC for the lost of moral judgment.

  9. Sorry, spinners. The Phil Martin stuff was another real problem for Thompson, whether you like it or not. That’s why he got rid of him, natch. Nice rationalizations, though.

Leave a Reply

Click here to subscribe to the Daily Digest, to stay up to date with the latest at PJ Media. (You will be sent an email asking you to verify your email address. If you have previously subscribed, no verification email will be sent.)