News
Directly To
Your Inbox
Follow PJ Media

Islamist Groups Push Conspiracy Theories in Homegrown Terror Cases

It's all a big plot by the FBI and state prosecutors to smear Muslims, don't you know?

by
Brendan Goldman and Shireen Qudosi

Bio

August 3, 2009 - 12:00 am
Page 1 of 2  Next ->   View as Single Page

“Our Koran is off limits,” said Hussam Ayloush, executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) Los Angeles chapter. “Our youth, who they try to radicalize, are off limits. Now is the time to tell them, ‘We’re not going to let this happen anymore.’”

The above statement, taken out of context, might read like a condemnation of radical Islamists who target young American Muslims. It’s not. The “they” and “them” in the quotation above refer not to al-Qaeda, but to the FBI. That such a conflation is possible is indicative of how leaders of “mainstream” American Muslim organizations have distorted the critical issue of confronting homegrown terrorism.

Ayloush was responding to the arrest in February of Ahmadullah Sais Niazi, a naturalized American of Afghan descent who is accused of perjury, naturalization fraud, misuse of a passport obtained by fraud, and making false statements to a federal agency, including denying that he had met with Amin al-Haq, his brother-in-law and Osama bin Laden’s former security coordinator, in Pakistan in 2005.

Advertisement

Instead of dealing with the facts of the case, the Islamists at CAIR and the Islamic Shura Council of Southern California attacked the credibility of the state prosecutor, Assistant U.S. Attorney Deirdre Eliot, and the government’s primary witness, 46-year-old FBI informant and father of four Craig Monteilh. In their magazines and in the blogosphere, the Islamists accuse Eliot of anti-Muslim sentiments and note that Monteilh has served time in prison. The facts of the arrest itself are relegated to later paragraphs or not mentioned at all.

In Focus, CAIR’s magazine, asserts that Eliot “runs the risk of being guilty by association herself for supporting a right-wing group that has promoted anti-Islamic rhetoric on its websites.” The group the magazine is referring to is the Lincoln Club of Orange County, an organization dedicated to “limited government, free enterprise, the rule of law, and the preservation of individual liberty.” Defaming Islam, apparently, did not make the cut.

PJ Media appreciates your comments that abide by the following guidelines:

1. Avoid profanities or foul language unless it is contained in a necessary quote or is relevant to the comment.

2. Stay on topic.

3. Disagree, but avoid ad hominem attacks.

4. Threats are treated seriously and reported to law enforcement.

5. Spam and advertising are not permitted in the comments area.

These guidelines are very general and cannot cover every possible situation. Please don't assume that PJ Media management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment. We reserve the right to filter or delete comments or to deny posting privileges entirely at our discretion. Please note that comments are reviewed by the editorial staff and may not be posted immediately. If you feel your comment was filtered inappropriately, please email us at story@pjmedia.com.

10 Comments, 10 Threads

  1. 1. Moho

    Here’s a more pertinent headline:

    “White Republicans Push Conspiracy Theories in American Born President Case”

  2. 2. fnord

    “I am very concerned that the hard work of building bridges here in Newburgh over the last quarter of a century will now be dismissed, because of the actions of a convicted felon,”

    How exactly does that amount to a conspiracy charge? Its the exact same statement that the jewish rabbis of NJ is using. Rotten apples, etc.

  3. 3. David S

    Protecting oneself from the FBI is just common sense. Knowing one’s rights when confronted by law enforcement is important – education on this topic is a public service, not an indication of “betrayal”.

    It is clear that the FBI and CIA have been operating in a far too permissive environment for years now, and that some time will be required to re-calibrate the restraint needed by these agencies.

    Blaming “Islamist” groups (aren’t they Muslim?) for pushing conspiracies is rather naive when one reflects upon the nature of the GOP assault on Islam and America. It is not the jihadis who are tapping our phones, reading our mail, and detaining US citizens indefinitely without charge.

    The FBI deserves every bit of criticism it is receiving.

    Peace.

    DS

  4. 4. Lynn B

    Moho @ #1
    How many of the “birthers” are plotting to blow things up? How many have been caught planning to blow things up? How many have threatened to kill other Americans? How many attend a church or synagogue which espouses hatred for the kafir? So, while the “birthers” are wrong in their assumption (IMHO) concerning the legality of Obama’s citizenship, they have not committed any crime unlike the Muslim nutters who have. Your strawman argument is just stupid.

  5. 5. Lynn

    Poor CAIR, angry that their ‘minority’ ingredient of hate, and intolerance sprinkled in our melting pot make some of us sick, and we no longer want it listed in the recipe.

    Please, let them be reminded, that if they have a problem with being a minority in this country, and have a problem with our law enforcement authorities doing their job to root out enemies who wish to kill us, there is an area that takes up approximately one-fourth of the world where they will be a majority, and can live among the like-minded.

    Would they like a donation to help pay for the moving costs?

    On second thought better we deal with them here, Israel doesn’t need any more humans who wish to wipe them from the face of the earth.

  6. 6. Anonymous

    “How many of the “birthers” are plotting to blow things up? How many have been caught planning to blow things up? How many have threatened to kill other Americans?”

    Are you serious? I’m afraid to find out.

  7. 7. Rob

    David S. Your comments do not stand up to criticism. I do agree that it is important for citizens to know and understand their rights, those rights protect them from oppressive government. However, it should not be encouraged to refuse assisting law enforcement authorities in identifying and capturing violent radicals and preventing their plans from coming to fruition. I am sure your stance might be different if we were discussing radical and violent pro-life groups/individuals.

    There is no GOP assault on Islam and America, that would be a conspiracy theory, and one easily dismissed given that the Democrat majority continues those same policies and in fact seeks to use them for more nefarious purposes (ala the privacy agreement for clunkers for cash). It would be more accurate (and honest) to recognize the outright constitutional violations perpetrated by the federal government over the course of decades and seek to reverse them, which is a very conservative type of issue (Libertarians anyone?). While the patriot act was wrong, I personally believe that it originated from the best of intentions to streamline the process of obtaining information. Who wants their family killed by a bombing that could have been stopped if the FBI wasn’t still waiting for that wire tap warrant and missing out on key intel? I think it was enacted without careful consideration for the violations of civil liberties it would allow because in post 9/11 America, we were and in some cases still are, in reactionary mode.

    In fact, there is no assault on Islam at all. This is an imagined policy concocted to protect the violent radical groups that emerge, from the Muslim community, by the radicals themselves. What better smokescreen than to claim persecution of Islam as a whole and secure special protections under the law not afforded other religions. A protective umbrella under which they are able to spread their poison while pretending to be the same as the friends, neighbors and co-workers that we know to be Muslim.

    Nobody is being plucked from the streets to be detained without having some connection with terrorist organizations, not yet anyway, but with big-brother government that the left is trying to force on us, it soon may be a reality.

  8. 8. polkabout

    6. Anonymous:

    Are you serious? I’m afraid to find out.

    With such absurd & farcical fears, how can you function in the real world.
    Oh, that’s right, you can’t. Your world is make believe.

  9. 9. Leatherneck

    CAIR, and the Muslim brotherhood are enemys of these United States. More, and more Americans are learning about the religion of peace.

    ROPMA!

  10. 10. Thomas

    @1. Moho:
    You said:
    ““White Republicans Push Conspiracy Theories in American Born President Case”

    You get the answer if you google: “”EXECUTIVE ORDER 13489″
    First day on throne the JOCKER sealed all his personal records for no apparent reason; – no other pres. ever did thing like that. To wit, we must know nothing about his background and actions: therefore our suspicions and doubt are well founded.

    Are you capable of comprehend the consequences of hiding EVERYTHING from the voters and for this action he paid about $1 million legal fees.

    You are the staunch defender of the Jocker and the oppressed people of color so I respectfully ask you to relate us the story: how turned Hussein Obama in Hawaii to Barry Soetero in the Indonesian school and back again to Hussein Obama? Thanks

Leave a Reply

We know you're busy. Sign up for our Daily Digest email to get a quick look each day at our editors' picks and readers' favorite stories. (You will receive an email asking you to verify your email address. If you have previously subscribed, no verification email will be sent.)