Get PJ Media on your Apple

Immigration Bill Heads to Senate Floor

Judiciary Committee passes behemoth bill 13-5 after working through hundreds of amendments; opponents say fight is not over.

by
Bridget Johnson

Bio

May 21, 2013 - 6:28 pm
Page 1 of 2  Next ->   View as Single Page

With Washington immersed in and distracted by a trio of scandals, the giant immigration reform bill is headed to the Senate floor after five days of amendments in the Judiciary Committee.

The vote was 13-5, with Republican Sens. Jeff Flake of Arizona, Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and Orrin Hatch of Utah joining the 10 Democrats on the committee to pass the bill.

GOP Sens. John Cornyn and Ted Cruz of Texas, Chuck Grassley of Iowa, Mike Lee of Utah and Jeff Sessions of Alabama voted against it.

The original 844-page bill from the Group of Eight emerges from committee molded by a bevy of amendments, including 48 from Republicans that were adopted.

Gang of Eight member Sen. Robert Menendez (D-N.J.), though, said he was “pleased to see that the original foundation of our legislation was not weakened.”

“Our carefully crafted compromise withstood a tough series of poison pill amendments, and its passage out of the Judiciary Committee brings us a step closer to final passage by the senate,” said Menendez, who does not sit on the committee. “Members from the entire political spectrum continue to support the bipartisan proposal put forth; this is the right approach at the right time. I will continue to do everything I can to push this bill across the finish line, and I look forward to a thoughtful and fair debate in the senate floor.”

Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.), also a member of the original negotiating group but not on the committee that marked up his bill, said he thought the committee “made real improvements to the bill.”

“The amended bill that heads to the Senate floor would make significant progress to secure our borders, make E-Verify mandatory for the first time in American history, effectively crack down on immigrants who overstay visas, and modernize the legal immigration system to meet America’s 21st century economic needs for both highly skilled talent and guest workers to fill labor shortages,” Rubio said.

However, he added, the reform bill won’t be successful “unless we can earn the confidence of the American people that we are solving our immigration problems once and for all.”

“As evidenced by the statements of many of my colleagues who voted against the bill in committee today, the vast majority of Americans across the political spectrum are prepared to give millions of people living here today illegally the opportunity to earn legal status and, potentially, permanent residence and citizenship – but only if they pay fines, pass background checks, don’t receive federal benefits and wait in line behind everybody who followed the rules,” Rubio said. “And only if we secure the border and take steps that ensure that we will never again have another wave of illegal immigration.”

Cornyn said he felt the markup made some improvements, but ultimately the legislation fell short of what was needed to get his vote.

“I was disappointed the Committee rejected an amendment I offered that would’ve required real border security results. Another promise from Washington, D.C., to secure the border won’t cut it,” he said. “I am deeply concerned about this and other flaws in the current proposal. I want the system to work for everyone, and I am hopeful that common sense will eventually lead to common ground.” 

Sessions, whose opposition to the legislation was especially vocal during the markup, highlighted a letter just released by a coalition of conservative activists urging lawmakers to vote against the bill and saying “no matter how well-intentioned, the Schumer-Rubio bill suffers from fundamental design flaws that make it unsalvageable.”

“Many of us support various parts of the legislation, but the overall package is so unsatisfactory that the Senate would do better to start over from scratch,” says the letter, which also urges senators to vote against cloture and keep the bill from coming up for a vote. Signatories include PJ Media’s Allen West, Victor Davis Hanson and Andrew McCarthy.

“The coalition letter is an important and decisive moment in this debate, reflecting deep, broad and principled conservative opposition,” Sessions said. “They note, correctly, that the Gang of Eight legislation is like Obamacare—a large, unwieldy bill filled with broken promises and special interest giveaways. The letter makes crucial points about how the Gang of Eight legislation will pull down Americans’ wages, destroy American jobs and erode the constitutional rule of law as immigration officers have repeatedly warned. While the number of voices supporting the Gang of Eight legislation shrinks, the number of Americans speaking out against this proposal continues to grow.”

Comments are closed.

All Comments   (22)
All Comments   (22)
Sort: Newest Oldest Top Rated
Here at ground zero in southern Arizona where the border is a sham we are supposed to be a Republican state with two entrenched Republican senators. So we have the doddering old fool McLame who gave us Obama and the hero of the Phoenix power base Jeff Flake bought, sealed and delivered by the open borders crowd. Poetic justice if they both get voted out for Democrats with the influx of compesinos over the borders (that's peasants for you unenlightened gringos)
Rubio is Charlie Crist with a real tan, a media created phony with the heart tugging story , the immigrant Horatio Alger. In reality open borders bring Sinaloa cartel gangbangers, tuberculosis, unassimilated Hispanic racists who hate whites, long lines at the food stamp office,etc.
But hey , we'll get some tasty new unsanitary taco trucks where liberal douchebags can get wear their "si si puede" tee shirts and feel good about themselves.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
The issue is bigger than Mexico: Supposedly this bill includes a huge expansion of the visa program for highly-trained tech specialists to flock here to do those well-paid, education-intensive, middle-class jobs that Americans just won't do.

An old friend of mine, a reservist and Iraq veteran, was fired "for cause" from his job in tech support at a well-regarded public university only three months after a positive, nay glowing, performance review. They did not share with him the details of why. He has three children, one with extensive special needs, and a visually-impaired wife. In his place the university has hired two brand-new arrivals from Taiwan, both half his age, each at half his salary.

I believe my country has fallen into the hands of its active enemies.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
We'd be better off just giving California to Mexico. That'd kill two birds with a single stone.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
The giant immigration reform bill is headed to the Senate floor after five days of amendments in the Judiciary Committee.
__________________________________

Under the smoke-screen of Benghazi et al no less. This smacks of the same tactics used to ramrod the (UN)Affordable Care Act through the Senate. Screw We the People over as we're focusing on Christmas - err - Winter Break - or was that Quanza? Damn - can't keep my PC talking points straight any more. At any rate we're all likely to wake up some morning real soon to find we have 20-25 million more of 'US' here. There is a 'here' 'here' isn't there?
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
This foolish "bill" is literally the death kneel of America. So long USA & hello anarchy!
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
As a foreigner, interested in American politics, I would like to know why the US doesn't just take over Mexico. It is even more poorly run than Vermont, and would probably love becoming the 58th state!
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
Rubio dutifully mouths the old mendacious "long and arduous path to citizenship", wink-wink, smirk-smirk, oh the pain and suffering, oh the humanity, but who would believe him? In any case if their status is legalized, why would they even want full citizenship? This is like a 'father' saying "You can have all the sex with my daughter you want, any and all of you, but for me to give you her hand in marriage, well I'm going to make that very difficult for you". This 'Father' Rubio, who would treat his own country like this, is not a very talented shyster at all, just a rank amateur and poor player, and certainly no Bill Clinton, except in his basic lack of honesty and honor, and in this he exceeds even Bill Clinton.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
Remember this from National Review?

Robert Bork’s America is a land in which women would be forced into back-alley abortions, blacks would sit at segregated lunch counters, rogue police could break down citizens’ doors in midnight raids, schoolchildren could not be taught about evolution, writers and artists could be censored at the whim of the government, and the doors of the federal courts would be shut on the fingers of millions of citizens.

The high-immigration Right has borrowed not only its immigration-policy views from Ted Kennedy, but now his political tactics as well. Grover Norquist, Linda Chavez, American Conservative Union president Al Cardenas — and Senator Marco Rubio — have launched a campaign to Bork those on the right who disagree with President Obama’s immigration plans.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
When Cruz introduced an amendment to deny state and federal welfare benefits to undocumented workers (because, you know, there aren't supposed to be any more illegals after immigration reform anyway), Durbin screeched, "What kind of America are you thinking of here, Senator Cruz?"

Cruz shot back: "The proponents of this bill have been on TV frequently saying those who are here illegally would not be eligible for welfare. My friend from IL gave impassioned speech as to why he believes we have moral obligation to extend benefits to those here illegally."

He warned committee members that there was a disconnect between what Durbin and others were saying and what would end up in the bill.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
"I am Robert of Bork. We will add your uniqueness to ours. Your purpose from this moment on will be to service----us. Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated."
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
Rubio is a Trojan Horse to Mexicanate America and an exceedingly obvious one. And his foreign policy views (we must support the “rebels”!) are those of a crackpot. He helped to bring about Benghazi.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
Obama and Rubio - The Tag Team for the Destruction of America.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
1 2 Next View All

One Trackback to “Immigration Bill Heads to Senate Floor”