Get PJ Media on your Apple

Governor’s Races: One Contest and One No Contest

A preview of the Virginia and New Jersey governor's races.

by
Rich Baehr

Bio

November 4, 2013 - 8:27 am

New Jersey Republican Governor Chris Christie is cruising towards a decisive victory in his campaign for re-election. The only question is whether his margin is so large that it automatically places him in the top tier of GOP presidential candidates in 2016, given that New Jersey is a reliably blue state won by President Obama in 2012 by 17%.

Christie, who was first elected in a race against scandal-tainted Democratic Governor John Corzine by about 4% in 2009, has been riding a wave of support since his handling of “Superstorm Sandy” in the week before the 2012 presidential election. Some polls suggest Christie could win by 25-30 points, with the closest poll showing him ahead by 19% over Democratic state Senator Barbara Buono.

Christie’s margin of victory will almost certainly exceed that of former Newark Mayor Cory Booker, who won a special election to fill the U.S. Senate seat of Frank Lautenberg, the Democratic senator who died in June. Booker won by 10% over Republican Steve Lonegan in the election held on October 16. Christie selected the date for the special election for Lautenberg’s seat, choosing one that was three weeks before the regular November election date for the governor’s race.

Some speculated that his motive was avoiding having both races decided on the November election day, so as to limit the minority turnout (mainly African Americans) in Christie’s race, as this could cut into his own margin of victory. Christie said he picked the earlier date for the special election since he wanted the Senate vacancy filled sooner rather than later. Polls have shown Christie doing significantly better than most Republicans among African American voters. The governor has campaigned in African American areas, and has maintained good relations with Booker, the state’s most prominent African American politician. Buono will almost certainly win the African American vote decisively, but not by the Barack Obama-sized margins of his presidential races (95% to 4% in 2008, 93% to 6% in 2012).

It is no secret that Christie is interested in running for president in 2016. Excerpts from a new book on the 2012 campaign reveal that Christie was considered for the 2012 vice presidential nomination by GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney, and that he was one of the five finalists for the spot eventually offered to Wisconsin Congressman Paul Ryan. The book claims that Christie was passed over in part due to Romney’s concerns about his health, mainly associated with Christie’s weight,  as well as issues relating to his career prior to becoming governor.

Christie delivered the keynote address at the 2012 GOP convention, and his talk made almost no reference to Romney, the Republican standard-bearer about to be nominated. When President Obama visited New Jersey after “Superstorm Sandy,” he was warmly greeted by Christie, and the two seemed to be a team. Given that their meet-up took place just days before the presidential election, the bipartisanship exhibited by both men to address storm victims and damage seemed to give Obama a lift in the national polls heading towards the finish line. It also seemed to give Christie a political boost in New Jersey, where Obama is popular. Obama’s eventual national margin of victory (4%) doubled in the last week of the race.

It is, of course, very early to be assessing a candidate’s chances to be nominated and to win in 2016. Hillary Clinton is virtually certain to be the Democratic nominee, since it is most unlikely that she will skip the race to stay home baking, waiting for grandchildren, collecting royalties from her next ghostwritten collection of memoirs, and making the occasional speech for Goldman Sachs and others for several hundred thousand dollars a pop. Clinton is an extraordinarily focused politician, and has had her eye on the White House since her husband first ran for the office, if not before.

Christie has run well in early head-to-head polling against Clinton, suggesting a broader support level in certain areas of the country and among certain groups than other Republicans who are considered likely candidates for the nomination in 2016. Kentucky Senator Rand Paul has also shown some crossover appeal due to his libertarian streak. Peggy Noonan has argued that Christie’s ability to win decisively in a blue state is due in large part to his everyman appeal. He is neither the Wall Street candidate nor the candidate of the  Tea Party, but rather someone who seems to enjoy being out with voters and is seen as a problem-solver, with some of the retail political skills of Bill Clinton.

Given the deep divisions in the Republican Party, even a 30-point win on Tuesday will not automatically catapult Christie to frontrunner status. There are reservations among conservatives that he is too moderate, and that moderates lost the last two elections (McCain and Romney). In any case, given the unpopularity of Congress — and in particular, Republicans in Congress —  successful governors such as Christie, Wisconsin’s Scott Walker (who also has won twice in a blue state), and Indiana’s Mike Pence will all be in the mix for 2016.

Virginia’s governor’s race has a entirely different feel. The outcome has become a bit less certain over the last week, with most polls showing a tightening race. Democrat Terry McAuliffe seemed to be headed for a decisive win, with three separate polls giving him leads of 12 points or more over the Republican candidate, Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli.

McAuliffe has stuck closely to the Obama 2012 campaign script in his second race for governor, raising huge sums of money early on. He nearly doubled the fundraising of Cuccinelli ($34 million to $19 million). McAuliffe’s media campaign has focused almost exclusively on the themes Obama used effectively against Mitt Romney, utilizing constant negative attacks on his opponent such as “the Republicans’ alleged war on women,” while trying to taint Cuccinelli with the scandals of current Republican Governor Bob McDonnell. McAuliffe also got a boost from the effort by some congressional Republicans that resulted in the shutdown of the federal government for the first two weeks of October. In a state heavily dependent on government salaries and contracts, the two week confrontation launched by the Tea Party and its supporters played very poorly.

Cuccinelli has now pulled within striking range in two recent polls — 2% behind in an Emerson College poll, and 4% behind in a Quinnipiac College poll. Almost all of the polling in both New Jersey and Virginia has been conducted by college-associated polling groups, rather than by national polling organizations. In the presidential race in Virginia in 2012, the national polls were right on the mark, with Obama winning the state by 4%, exactly his national margin of victory.

Cuccinelli’s surge is likely associated with the extremely incompetent rollout of the Obamacare health care exchanges, as well as by the recent barrage of stories detailing that millions of Americans with individual insurance policies have already been dropped by insurance companies as a result of the non-compliance of the existing policies with Obamacare mandates for coverage. These stories about insurance company actions have put defenders of the new health care law such as McAuliffe in a defensive posture, since President Obama claimed for almost four years that people who liked their doctors or their plans would get to keep them.

Cuccinelli, on the other hand, was an early foe of Obamacare and challenged the law in court. After two weeks of the race being nationalized on terms very favorable to McAuliffe (the debt ceiling fight and government shutdown), now the race has been impacted by national news  far more favorable to the Republican nominee (big government incompetence and Obama lies). Barack Obama will campaign for McAuliffe in the final days, trying to stimulate heavy minority turnout, but his visit may focus even more attention on the health care law.

The Virginia race has a bit of added uncertainty due to a third party candidate, Robert Sarvis, running as a Libertarian. Sarvis has consistently polled at levels over 10%. Normally, the vote total of third party candidates sinks on election day from prior polling levels when the race is close between the two major party candidates. Ralph Nader polled at 5% or higher before the 2000 race, but failed to reach 3% of the actual popular vote. Sarvis’ polling numbers have shown no sign of dropping off as Cuccinelli has edged closer to McAuliffe (a lead of 5% for McAuliffe on average in the last five polls), and Sarvis seems to be picking up some support from people who have moved away from McAuliffe. Both McAuliffe and Cuccinelli are far better known than Sarvis, and most Virginia voters seem unhappy with both of them. From the Emerson College survey:

All the candidates continue to have higher unfavorable than favorable ratings, with McAuliffe’s at 37 percent favorable to 52 percent unfavorable and Cuccinelli at 38 percent to 56 percent. Third party candidate Sarvis is also disliked with a 22 percent unfavorable rating and a 19 percent favorable rating.

The Virginia race will likely be decided by turnout, where Democrats, with their more technologically sophisticated get-out-the-vote operations, have excelled in the Obama era. Virginia is considered a purple state, but Democrats have won both Senate races and the last two presidential races. Republicans had their day in the state races in 2009 and in House races in 2010. Unless there is a significant shift from Sarvis to Cuccinelli in the next few days, McAuliffe appears headed to a mid-single-digit victory. In any case, there is undoubtedly more nervousness this weekend in the McAuliffe camp than there was last weekend. There is also nervousness in the Hillary Clinton household, since having Clinton ally McAuliffe in the Virginia governor’s chair would be a boost to her 2016 candidacy.

Richard A. Baehr is the co-founder and chief political correspondent for the American Thinker. For his day job, he has been a health care consultant for many years doing planning and financial analyses for providers.

Comments are closed.

Top Rated Comments   
Christie will win in New Jersey, because there is no measurable objective difference in his actions from those of a Leftist Democrat. In his own words:

>>>‘I’m not much different from Andrew Cuomo. I probably agree with him on 98% of the issues.’<<<

http://hotair.com/archives/2013/02/19/chris-christie-i-agree-with-andrew-cuomo-on-probably-98-of-the-issues/

Cuccinelli will lose because of lack of support from the Institutional Republicans who consider his conservatism to be more dangerous than a victory of Hillary's surrogate. That and the population of voting parasites centered around Capitol City overwhelms the state to the point that it is impossible for a Republican statewide candidate to get beyond the Democrat margin-of-fraud.

And the RNC will consider that combination a win for their purposes.

Subotai Bahadur
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
Many Republicans? Which ones . . . the ones that put up McCain against Obama & muzzled Palin in 08? The ones that let Al Franken steal a Senate seat in Minnesota? The ones that let George W. Bush expand the Dept of Education & push for amnesty for illegals? Those Republicans?
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
One Republican will cruise to victory and the other race is tight. Bet the farm that no matter the outcome(s), the media will spin this as 'conservatism is dead', the 'Tea Party is finished', 'extreme right takes a beating' or some other such nonsense.
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
All Comments   (23)
All Comments   (23)
Sort: Newest Oldest Top Rated
my classmate's step-aunt makes $84/hour on the laptop. She has been fired for six months but last month her paycheck was $21258 just working on the laptop for a few hours. check this link right here now.....
http://www.Jobs37.com
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
Want to start making some extra money every month? Want to earn in the range of 2000-8000$ every month? You can...It's all up to you and your desire to learn how. We will be your guides and show you how to reach your goals... Don't miss it!!! For more information, visit following website====== www.jobs83.com
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
Gianna. if you think Randy`s blurb is neat, yesterday I picked up a great Smart ForTwo from having made $4671 this-last/month an would you believe ten-grand this past-munth. it's actualy the best work I've ever done. I began this 7-months ago and straight away began to earn more than $78 per hour. my website http://www.jobs64.com
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
Everybody can earn 150$+ daily... You can earn from 4000-9000 a month or even more if you work as a full time job...It's easy, just follow instructions on this page, read it carefully from start to finish... It's a flexible job but a good earning opportunity.. go to this site----> WWW.Rush64.COM
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
My last pay check was 9500 dolr working 12 hours a week online. My sisters friend has been averaging 15k for months now and she works about 20 hours a week. I can't believe how easy it was once I tried it out.........>>>>>>>> http://xurl.es/z16n0
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
A story is just breaking this morning (http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2013/11/libertarian_con_in_virginia_governors_race_revealed.html) --when it can't be widely enough distributed to effect the election--alleging that it was a major Democratic contributor and wealthy Obama bundler who was the major donor to the Libertarian Booster PAC, which paid for the people who collected the signatures that got the Libertarian candidate on the ballot i.e. the Libertarian's candidacy is a Democratic "dirty trick," designed to "split" the conservative vote and to siphon off enough votes from Cucinelli so that McAuliffe can win.
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
my buddy's step-mother makes $76 hourly on the laptop. She has been without work for nine months but last month her pay was $16208 just working on the laptop for a few hours. check here___>>>> www.bay89.com
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
my best friend's aunt makes $72 an hour on the internet. She has been laid off for ten months but last month her pay was $19385 just working on the internet for a few hours. site..... WWW.Rush64.Com
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
Leroy answered I'm amazed that any one able to make $4106 in one month on the computer. about his----> W­W­W.F­­b­­3­­­9.Ⅽ­­­O­­­Ⅿ
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
If McAuliffe had not been handed the three-week vacation from the rollout of Obama-Care by the stupid shutdown, Cuccinelli would have already taken the lead. But in order to support a couple of grandstanders with only their own ambitions at heart, we effectively shortened the campaign by those weeks when the shutdown sucked all the media oxygen.

37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
"If McAuliffe had not been handed the three-week vacation from the rollout of Obama-Care by the stupid shutdown"

The shutdown--which should have been followed by the end of the CR--is the only reason I can think of bother to vote this November, in 2014, or 2016.
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
1 2 Next View All