Get PJ Media on your Apple

Generation Kill: Not the Greatest Generation

The new HBO miniseries on Iraq is well-executed, but its anti-war bias is clear.

by
Christian Toto

Bio

July 13, 2008 - 12:00 am
Page 1 of 2  Next ->   View as Single Page

The first episode — or more specifically the first 20 minutes — of HBO’s new miniseries Generation Kill confirms a conservative’s worst fears about HBO’s latest Iraq project.

Right away the Marines depicted are casually racist, homophobic and ignorant beyond reproach. They complain about the lack of supplies, decry their mission and mock letters of support from children back home. One Marine goes so far as to describe the little girl who wrote one of the letters as “hot.”

The dialogue also pays the mission no favors.

“It’s destiny, dawg. White man’s gotta rule the world,” says one Marine of color, while another jokes that his fellow Marines going in to “loot and pillage a country.”

No one comes anywhere near supporting the invasion.

Yet Kill, based on the nonfiction book by embedded reporter Evan Wright, overcomes its initial bombardment of anti-soldier sentiment.

Generation Kill delivers a remarkably realistic glimpse of modern warfare. Soldiers get casualty updates via the Web. Marines bring their own video cameras on the front lines when they’re not snapping digital pictures of the action. They sing hip-hop anthems while driving into battle.

This isn’t the Greatest Generation.

The miniseries, which begins at 9 p.m. EST July 13, follows the Marines of the First Reconnaissance Battalion who led the charge in the Iraq war’s first few days. The miniseries tracks their progress through Iraq, their mission changing every day, and sometimes every hour. Chaos and a total lack of proper management are the hallmark of the invasion’s early chapters, to hear Kill’s take on the material. But then how did the U.S. forces manage to topple Saddam Hussein’s army so efficiently?

The first of seven hour-long episodes is so unrelentingly negative it may take a miracle for viewers to tune in next week. Even the first hour’s lone positive, a scene in which Marines get surprised by stacks of pizza boxes, turns sour when they learn the slices aren’t free.

We’re told much of the dialogue, and action, came straight from Wright’s notebook. But a good dramatist understands the need for balance. Instead, the miniseries spends too much time focusing on every military misstep, the camera lingering on dead Iraqi bodies as long as possible.

Kill improves measurably in its second and subsequent hours, falling into a tense pattern of battles and pre-attack banter. Don’t expect the typical Hollywood action sequences. The assaults come from nowhere, and often end before a dozen shots are fired.

The dialogue is raw but flows remarkably well, lending the project a hyper-realism few war films can muster. Overlapping conversations aren’t easy to pull off, but Kill’s tight cast makes it sound natural and unrehearsed. The military jargon comes out easily from these actors’ mouths, and the gaggle of on-set advisors make sure maximum authenticity is achieved. It’s the closest you’ll come to hearing what it’s like between mortar assaults.

Click here to view the 103 legacy comments

Comments are closed.