Get PJ Media on your Apple

Did Bill O’Reilly Kill Dr. George Tiller?

The Fox News host is being accused of inciting the violence that led to the high-profile murder.

by
Melissa Clouthier

Bio

June 2, 2009 - 12:15 am
Page 1 of 2  Next ->   View as Single Page

Notorious late-term abortion practitioner Dr. George Tiller was gunned down on his way to church on Sunday. Motives and details are still being sorted out, but his murder prompted insanity all around — the best demonstration of which was forwarded by Salon writer Gabriel Winnant:

But there’s no other person who bears as much responsibility for the characterization of Tiller as a savage on the loose, killing babies willy-nilly thanks to the collusion of would-be sophisticated cultural elites, a bought-and-paid-for governor and scofflaw secular journalists.

Winnant was referring to Bill O’Reilly.

Winnant is implying that O’Reilly incited the murder of Dr. Tiller because he reported heavily on him and used catchy headlines like “Tiller the Baby Killer“:

The Factor has learned that Tiller was aborting babies of girls aged 10-15, including victims of forcible rape, “and those abortions were not reported to authorities as required by law,” Bill said, “so the criminals who impregnated the girls have so far gotten away with it.”

The guest on the Factor the night of November 3 was the aforementioned Kansas Attorney General Kline. “[In] every single instance, there was not a late-term abortion performed on a viable child to save the life of the mother,” Kline asserted, “and in every single instance, there was not an abortion performed for a physical reason.” So according to the records, Tiller was using “depression” (and that, Bill concluded, “could be anything”) as an excuse to terminate these pregnancies.

“When you have a 10- or 11-year-old child who is pregnant, and gets an abortion, and no one calls the police, it’s likely a family member that is abusing that child,” said Kline. In Kansas, sexual intercourse with a child under 14 is defined as “rape” because the child is below the age of consent, which means any pregnant girl under 14 getting an abortion at Tiller’s clinic is the victim of a crime and Tiller is required to inform authorities. AG Kline indicated Tiller is not reporting the rapes, a felony under Kansas law.

This reporting from O’Reilly posted two years ago. Does Winnant really believe that such a dated article served as the catalyst for Sunday’s murder? Or is he just exploiting a convenient story to paint his ideological enemies as psychopaths?

Either way, it’s massive hypocrisy and lazy, subjective reasoning. Leftists like Winnant love their free speech, unless it’s speech they prefer not to hear. Recall when Tipper Gore went on a similar anti-free speech rampage? When the controversial messages come from the worlds of art or music, we get liberal outrage when someone suggests they’ve gone too far. Tipper Gore challenges free speech in pop culture and becomes the enemy. When the controversial words come from a conservative like O’Reilly? Forget free speech. He, of course, must be silenced.

On Sunday, George Tiller is murdered and Bill O’Reilly is to blame.  Then, on Monday, two Army recruiters are shot — one murdered — and the response from the left is close to silence. Winnant cries against tough words and blames someone for inciting violence in the case of the abortion doctor’s death. Would he have been outraged had we found that the Army recruiters’ shooting was a politically motivated assassination? If a left-wing nut had been responding to the Tiller murder, would Winnant blame himself for the murderous incitement? Certainly Winnant could be amenable to the idea that the reporting and rhetoric surrounding the Tiller murder has been high-pitched and could incite a person to murder innocent soldiers, couldn’t he?

Click here to view the 261 legacy comments

Comments are closed.