Get PJ Media on your Apple

Dem Negotiator Laments House GOP Putting Down Its ‘Harmonious Hymnal’ on Immigration

Still, Luis Gutierrez and Paul Ryan keep their harmony: “How big and broad it is — the House will work its will and we’ll find out," Ryan said of the final product.

by
Bill Straub

Bio

June 21, 2013 - 3:50 pm
<- Prev  Page 2 of 2   View as Single Page

“I have tremendous respect for the members of the bipartisan group who have been working with me to fix our broken immigration system,” Labrador said, but the bill’s framework “changed in a way that I can no longer support.”

Still, the opportunity remains for a deal. Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.), chairman of the House Budget Committee and the 2012 GOP vice presidential candidate, has expressed his support for the House Gang of Eight effort and is contributing to the initiative.

“My motivation — and I think the vast majority of Republicans’ motivation — is we believe in the rule of law,” Ryan said. “We believe that we need to have better security of our border. And we want to make sure that we have laws that are adhered and followed, and we believe in economic growth. And when we’ve got baby boomers retiring — when we’ve got 10,000 people retiring every day, as they will be for 10 years coming — we’re going to need people.”

Ryan said he believes that eventually the House and Senate will engage in a conference committee over immigration reform and emerge with legislation that addresses the problem.

“How big and broad it is — the House will work its will and we’ll find out,” Ryan said. “The group that we have in the House I think has been extremely constructive. I think the border language that we’ve got, the rule-of-law language that we have would be a great improvement on the Senate product. So I think we’ll show, perhaps on some of these issues, better language from my perspective, from the Republicans’ perspective, on how to approach these issues.”

Ultimately, Ryan said, the legislation is not going to provide taxpayer-funded benefits for undocumented workers or those here on a probationary basis. Instead, the bill likely will make it  “so they can get affordable health insurance so that they don’t become a public charge.”

Ryan further argued that the proposal being debated does not constitute an amnesty for illegal immigrants already here.

“The idea is, a person gets a probationary status so that they come out of the shadows,” he said. “They get right with the law, and during that probationary status, they will have paid a fine. They will pay back taxes. We’ll make sure that they’re not a convicted felon. They’ll take civics classes. They’ll learn English. They’ll get right with the law. And then, after the probationary status expires, and after everybody who did everything right — who was already in the line — gets through the line, only until then — when they’re put at the back of the line — can they consider a status readjustment. This could take as long as 15 years if a person aspires to be a citizen with what we’re looking at in the House. That is not amnesty.”

Regardless, Gutierrez said as the 4th of July deadline favored by Democratic leaders to pass the bill approaches, “we get red meat politics for the barbecue and partisan fireworks on immigration” from Republicans.

“As a Democrat I should probably stand back and watch,” he said. “If you want to hang yourself on the immigration issue, who am I to stop you? But as an American I have to tell you what I really feel.”

“Come back to your senses,” he said.

<- Prev  Page 2 of 2   View as Single Page
Washington freelancer Bill Straub is former White House correspondent for Scripps Howard News Service.

Comments are closed.

Top Rated Comments   
" Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-Ill.) credited the Republican lawmakers he has been negotiating with, particularly Rep. John Carter (R-Texas), with trying to find a solution to the pressing problem of undocumented workers crossing the nation’s borders."
-----------------------------------------------------

As if further proof were needed that most politicians couldn't pour piss from a boot if the instructions were written on the heel - Rep. Gutierrez supplies additional redundant proof.

Rep Gutierrez would like us to believe that for over 225 years there have been no laws on the books to deter illegals from entering the US - so now we need to 'fix' things with some laws that we've been foolish enough not to have for lo all these centuries. What is really going on is an attempt to 'sweeten the milk' for illegals - sweeten things enough for more of them to flood across the border. Subsidies in health care are only one - I'm quite sure there are other sugar nuggets for the illegals.

And who will be there to meet the next wave of 2, 5, or 10 million illegals? Not the 20k new border agents - those new jobs will last about as long as as the proverbial snowball in hell. All the dems need to do is refuse to fund INS at the levels necessary to keep those 20k agents on the job. And they WILL have the votes to retake the house in a few years if this monstrosity gets signed into law.

Marco Rubio is a RINO who is running for president. If he can capture 10-15% of the hispanic vote he'll have a very good chance at becoming president in 2016. Beyond that personal goal he apparently has little regard for our nations long term health. This is the mark of the RINO - putting personal advance above God and Country.

Rubio is still 'new' - he'll need to be bent over hard by the democrats before he 'gets it'. By that time it'll be too late for Rubio - and we'll all have taken a collective 'BOHICA' (bend over here it comes again) as we watch the further erosions of our standards of living - privacy - and individual rights.



42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-Ill.) credited the Republican lawmakers he has been negotiating with, particularly Rep. John Carter (R-Texas), with trying to find a solution to the pressing problem of undocumented workers crossing the nation’s borders.

Stop 'em from coming across, and deport the ones already here as they are found. No-brainer, right?

Apparently, not for Gutierrez or the likes of him. (that includes amnesty-backing Republicans as well)
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
I find it amazin', simply amazin', that our legislators - professional politicians whom we voted for - are trying to manipulate a comprehensive immigration bill that will not offend illegal immigrants and their enablers among both Democrats and Republicans. Any other invasion by foreigners would have been met with force of arms at an earlier time in our history.

Instead of complying with applicable U. S. law, the invaders are dictating what we be in the bill!

It's amazin', amazin', stupidly amazin'!
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
All Comments   (16)
All Comments   (16)
Sort: Newest Oldest Top Rated
No point in any new bills until Tyrant Obama leaves office. He doesn't pay attention to the law or the Constitution.

After Tyrant Obama is removed from office we might be able to work out an agreement. It should make illegal immigration a serious felony and the same for those helping them with sanctuaries and such. A large portion of the FBI needs to be dedicated on pursuing these felons. Every employee must prove citizenship and illegals should get no benefits. Furthermore, any felons who receive amnesty cant bring in other foreigners or their family. They can never vote or receive welfare/social security.
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
Gutierrez presents a concoction, not terribly objectionable. However, as the witches brew that makes up the actual bill become known we find ourselves being seduced to take a fatal drink.
Beware the government agent coming with smiles and
romises of help.
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
The whole thing is BULL****. We already have a Immigration bill on the books and Captain Clownshoes does not enforce any of it unless it helps ILLEGAL ALIENS get the best of us. We already know that MORE illegals are running across the border every day now in anticipation of the big sellout. The R party is DEAD if this turd flies,Period.
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
John Carter, warlord of Austin?
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
Some things are not worth salvaging, meant to die and never resurrect themselves. Immigration "reform", really amnesty, should have been strangled in its infancy, but the multicultural psychotics won't allow it. Moreover, it doesn't seem to bother them that ILLEGAL acts are being rewarded through "reform".
No matter. Obama Inc is hell bent on pushing this through, he will never allow it to die. After all, to transform/bring down America one needs millions of illegals to do so - http://adinakutnicki.com/2013/04/02/adina-kutnickis-book-review-featured-at-american-thinker-bringing-down-america-an-fbi-informer-with-the-weathermen-written-by-larry-grathwohl-and-frank-reagan-updated-2013-edition/
May all the kumbayaniks spin and spin....
Adina Kutnicki, Israel http://adinakutnicki.com/about/
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
“I ask my Republican colleagues — when is it enough?”

It was enough, back in 1986. Some of us remember what happened back then, Congressman.
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
What's with this PC-speak re "undocumented workers"?

They are ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS! ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS! ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS!

Next time PJ Media comes around looking for money, I will remember how they outed themselves by signaling they are with the pro-amnesty crowd.

I hope other readers feel the same.

"Starve the beast" starts with websites that support the beast!!!

42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
No. They are criminals.
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
You are correct to question the "undocumented workers" and "undocumented immigrants" pity-party sloganeering. It is nonsense. The iillegals aren't "undocumented", they have documents and their documents are back in their country of origin. Duh.
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-Ill.) credited the Republican lawmakers he has been negotiating with, particularly Rep. John Carter (R-Texas), with trying to find a solution to the pressing problem of undocumented workers crossing the nation’s borders.

Stop 'em from coming across, and deport the ones already here as they are found. No-brainer, right?

Apparently, not for Gutierrez or the likes of him. (that includes amnesty-backing Republicans as well)
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
" Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-Ill.) credited the Republican lawmakers he has been negotiating with, particularly Rep. John Carter (R-Texas), with trying to find a solution to the pressing problem of undocumented workers crossing the nation’s borders."
-----------------------------------------------------

As if further proof were needed that most politicians couldn't pour piss from a boot if the instructions were written on the heel - Rep. Gutierrez supplies additional redundant proof.

Rep Gutierrez would like us to believe that for over 225 years there have been no laws on the books to deter illegals from entering the US - so now we need to 'fix' things with some laws that we've been foolish enough not to have for lo all these centuries. What is really going on is an attempt to 'sweeten the milk' for illegals - sweeten things enough for more of them to flood across the border. Subsidies in health care are only one - I'm quite sure there are other sugar nuggets for the illegals.

And who will be there to meet the next wave of 2, 5, or 10 million illegals? Not the 20k new border agents - those new jobs will last about as long as as the proverbial snowball in hell. All the dems need to do is refuse to fund INS at the levels necessary to keep those 20k agents on the job. And they WILL have the votes to retake the house in a few years if this monstrosity gets signed into law.

Marco Rubio is a RINO who is running for president. If he can capture 10-15% of the hispanic vote he'll have a very good chance at becoming president in 2016. Beyond that personal goal he apparently has little regard for our nations long term health. This is the mark of the RINO - putting personal advance above God and Country.

Rubio is still 'new' - he'll need to be bent over hard by the democrats before he 'gets it'. By that time it'll be too late for Rubio - and we'll all have taken a collective 'BOHICA' (bend over here it comes again) as we watch the further erosions of our standards of living - privacy - and individual rights.



42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
Can't say it better myself.
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
Never in my memory (which goes back a while) have I seen an issue that so divides the political elites from the common people. And it looks like the elites will have their way, regardless of popular opinion or the real impact of the bill on the country. They are so used to spinning in Washington it seems like the spin is all that is important and they have forgotten that the real impact of what they do is often far worse than predicted.
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
I find it amazin', simply amazin', that our legislators - professional politicians whom we voted for - are trying to manipulate a comprehensive immigration bill that will not offend illegal immigrants and their enablers among both Democrats and Republicans. Any other invasion by foreigners would have been met with force of arms at an earlier time in our history.

Instead of complying with applicable U. S. law, the invaders are dictating what we be in the bill!

It's amazin', amazin', stupidly amazin'!
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
If someone came here from another planet, having learned English from decades old radio broadcasts, they would think we had been at war with Mexico and Mexico won. Not won as big as we did against the Japaneses where there was an unconditional surrender, but pretty close to it, and we are now negotiating the almost unconditional surrender terms. How could we have been defeated by the Mexican army? We were not. Rubio and the Gang Bang Eight (and Ryan) sabotaged all our weapons and poisoned our water supply.
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
Illegal immigrants and the people that want them here raise a stink and make cowardly politicians if they don't get what they want from them. Republican voters on the other hand ALWAYS turn the other cheek and ask Karl Rove what should they do after the GOP stabs them in the back. If you allow politicians to stab you in the back and pay no price for it they will do it over and over. BTW, the politicians don't feel they have paid a price if you vote for them again but you have 1.3% less enthusiasm than last time you voted for them. If you play nice you get played. Park a bus full of angry demonstrators in front of their house, now you have the politician's attention.
42 weeks ago
42 weeks ago Link To Comment
View All