Attention Mayor Bloomberg: Lower SAT Scores Don’t Equal ‘Success’
The NYC mayor touts Chancellor Joel Klein's "accomplishments" while test scores keep dropping.
September 29, 2009 - 12:51 am
A spokesman for the city schools, Andrew Jacobs, said: “It is especially encouraging that so many more of our black and Hispanic students took the SAT this year, since far too few of these students have historically put themselves on track for college.” This statement, however, drips with sophistry. The number of minority students taking the SAT this year is about the same as those taking the exam last year. Moreover, is Mr. Jacobs claiming blacks and Hispanics cannot succeed on this test? What are the implications of that statement? And how does he square the relative success of minority students on New York City administered standardized tests with the relatively poor showing of this population on the SAT?
If the SAT scores demonstrate that New York City minority students are not prepared for college-level study, one must ask what are they prepared for. Most significantly, the poor results on the SAT test call into question some of the exaggerated claims about student performance. Do the New York City scores in reading and math truly support the proposition that the city’s students are showing marked improvement? Will Mayor Bloomberg be inclined to scale back his rhetoric about educational progress?
Perhaps the most noteworthy development from this recent report is that educational scholars are likely to examine the so-called progress in the city’s school system — or, at least, I hope so. It would surely be helpful to understand why students are doing so well on one hand and so poorly on the other.