Another Senior Iranian Military Official Defects
What is interesting about this case is that initially, the head of the refugee organization where Arian handed himself over to said that he had gone missing for a month. This prompted many to believe that the Iranian colonel had followed the same path as Asgari, and had been “kidnapped” by the Mossad or the CIA. However, a day after the initial report the report was corrected and the refugee authorities in the city of Van said that he had been found again.
This new development is likely to lead to a new shake-up in Iran’s intelligence apparatus. These defections show that senior officials are not being monitored in an effective manner. More importantly, they show that the level of dissatisfaction inside military circles is reaching new highs, which means that as well as defections, more people inside Iran may be encouraged to cooperate with Western intelligence agencies.
Iran will have to tread a fine line in this case. Relations with Turkey are very important for Tehran, both economically and politically. With Tehran becoming isolated, any damage caused in Tehran-Ankara relations will be to the benefit of the U.S. and Israel. On the other hand, Turkish authorities seem to be playing host to defectors from Iran, thus making the country a top destination for whoever wants to escape and to cause damage to Iran’s military apparatus. And what is even more interesting is that Turkey is not the only neighbor which seems to be playing a double game. Iranians are concerned about what they see as rise of CIA activity in the republic of Azerbaijan, and in Dubai where hundreds of thousands of Iranians live and work. This is in addition to an increase in anti-Iran intelligence activities by neutral countries such as Holland, which according to Dutch media has become successful in recruiting agents inside Iran. This truly is a dangerous phenomenon. Iranians who are against the government may still have ideological problems working for the U.S., Israel, or Arab countries, due to historical animosities. However, a country such as Holland with whom Iran has had no differences could resolve that problem by recruiting the agent, and then sharing intelligence with other countries. Or worst, American or Israeli agents may recruit Iranian agents by fooling them into believing that they are working for another more “neutral” country.
The fact that Barack Obama has offered to talk directly with Iran does not mean that the intelligence war between the two sides is over. In fact, the opposite is true. To conduct meaningful negotiations, the U.S. will have to rely on increased volume and quality of intelligence. The same goes for Tehran. The Iranian government will most probably be upping the tempo in its efforts to recruit its own agents. If its successes in Lebanon and Iraq are anything to go by, Western counterintelligence agencies will have their work cut out.






what is interesting is that you never hear of western military officers, or anyone of importance for that matter, defecting to iran or other islamic countries. i wonder why the defections are always one way, that is westward, hmm?
The article references a “double game.” I wonder whether these defectors are genuine. That is good news that CIA activity is supposedly rising in Azerbijian; ever since the Second World War the Iran/Russia relationship has been managed via Azerbijian. It makes one wonder whether Western reluctance to attack Iran’s nuclear capability hasn’t been because of political, military, or logistics problems, but because some country has already provided Iran with nuclear weapons sufficient to destroy Israel or threaten USA forward bases – that is, they are already effectively holding “the Satans” hostage?
…probably for the same reason that you never (or very rarely, at worst) hear of American citizens “defecting” to other countries–other than to escape prosecution for crimes committed in the U.S.
re: lack of defecting Americans.
Perhaps they are too valuable where they are? Perhaps our counter-intel is poor and they are rarely detected?
But, yes, presumably we have much fewer disaffected senior officials.
Its good news, one wonders if code pink could even fathom the level of evil in Iran that is driving out the people whose job it is to defend their country.
A colonel in the revolutionary guard or even in the regular army is of no importance inside of the Iranian military. There are thousands of colonels within the military who basically do nothing but got promoted because of their age and years of service. One has to be at least a Brig. General to handle anything beyond “secret” in the regime military circles.
In authoritarian countries, high level defectors may simply be losers in internal power struggles. In an environment in which loser die, people on the losing side seriously consider fleeing the country. This happens a lot all over the 3rd world but we simply do not notice it unless the defectors come from some place we pay attention to.
A lot of defectors usually indicates a constriction of patronage networks. The people at the top are creating an ever shrinking pool of people they trust. As the networks shrink, the regime will grow more paranoid and unstable even as they create an increasing population of those who would benefit from its fall.
I’ve met Iranian political refugees in Iraq who got out with the assistance of the Kurdish resistance. They were very grateful to the members of the moderate Komola who got them out. It takes a lot of courage to resist regimes like the Islamic Republic. One of the best ways to resist is to leave.
Not many Americans go overseas to defect because Americans can “defect” in place with no consequences.
Who dares call even the most strenuous and energetic “dissent” treason?
And when you are free to quit, and emigrate, what the heck does “defect” mean, anyway?
I expect the emigration rate to Iran from the West is pretty small, and limited to Islamic ideologues, though.
If I make enough money, I plan to defect to Australia. I’m tired of shoveling snow, and I like oogling girls in bikinis on the beach. I hope to get there before they are all wearing burkas.
Colonel is high level?
Please.
It would depend on which section of the armed forces he works…
Yeah, the only military defector I can recall is one Lee Harvey Oswald, who defected to the Soviet Union, but unfortunately did not remain there.
Winston:
A colonel in the revolutionary guard or even in the regular army is of no importance inside of the Iranian military. There are thousands of colonels within the military who basically do nothing but got promoted because of their age and years of service. One has to be at least a Brig. General to handle anything beyond “secret” in the regime military circles.
Garbage.
Most military intel comes from disaffected officers and even enlisteds well below flag rank.
It’s not like only Generals are stationed in missile or nuclear development billets rolling drums of yellowcake around or assembling rocket engines, or working as spies or doing all the procurement and staffing records keeping.
Good point of much of the intelligence being done by nations not as hated in the ME by the common man as the US or Israel..but shared at least with us. Besides the Dutch, the Germans and French are also in gathering intel and recruits, in force. And we are working the Iranian Azeris (30% of Iran’s population) through Azerbaijani agencies. Plus, the Kurds owe us from Iraq.
The more it goes on, hopefully, the more the average Iranian will question the Mullah’s policy of isolation. Of having no allies, and committing cross-border aggression and support of distant terrorist groups that do not have the welfare of Iranians anywhere on their list of priorities.
garbage cedarford, have you served in the Iranian military? You have not. I have and I know more than you do, moron. Get a life plz
I’m in agreement with cedarford. Intel folks can be the 1-2 striper to almost any officer rank under the sun. The analysts (those who take into account the data and assemble it for the higher-ups to peruse) are the ‘low men/women on the totem pole’ so to speak and know the information more times than not before the bosses do.
It’s why most enlisted people will rely upon or trust the ‘Chief’ before most officers. Lieutenants and in many instances Majors are extremely doe-eyed or even worse, kiss-ups. Their obtaining rank is similiar to the practices med school students use on their fellow students.
That being said, I hope more defectors and/or good news is abound.
Mr. Javedanfar,
I wouldn’t get SO excited yet. Until these people are vetted and the facts that they impart is sifted through, their voracity MUST be regarded with an EXCEEDINGLY squinty eye! The ones of us who have spent our lives working on Mullah issues should know better than to get excited about someone who could turn out to be a regime operative!
Banafsheh, I am willing to bet some top dollars that this so-called COLONEL will turn out to be a no-body. Dar akhar, siahi be zoghal mimooneh. LoL
@ 1…. No but there are plenty of Al Gore/Obama types who do. Alger Hess comes to mind.
Iran does not need an intelligence service, they have The New York Times.
I AM AGREE WITH RAND, …..
But I should say that unfortunatlly who ever is supporting Mullahs in Iran,they are looking for their money and thier oil that is all. even though they know these mullahs and ahmadinejat and … are killing, murduring, and torturing their own people, they are also killing Palastinian, Israeli, and also Iraqi people too.
I ask Rand and those who are against this inhuman government in Iran, to have a visit on our weblog (Students’ Committee). to know the reality in our country.
http://studentscommittee.blogfa.com
I welcome any contact to my email who is against this mullahs’ regime:
joan.baezo@gmail.com
Thank you
SARA
What sort fo insane person would want to defect from a free country like Sweeden or Norway, UK or Canada to a miserable Islamic country like Iran or Suadi Arabia for instance?!!
PS1- I am an Iranian by the way and I know what exactly I am talking about here.
PS2- A person living in a free country does not need to defect to another country, he or she simply travels to that country!!
“According to Tabnak’s Turkish sources, Colonel Arian escaped because he was against the torturing of Iranian opposition figures inside Iran.”
Interesting, no?
Our disgruntled officials defect–they defect to the New York Times or The Nation or Newsweek. Then those disgruntled, patriotic, officials get a nice book deal for their defection. In the heroic traditions of Jane Fonda and Tom Hayden, they go on to castigate their former colleagues as “chicken hawks” who never show up for the fight; curiously, I don’t recall seeing the New Left and their defectors humping the boonies with the Vietcong. Actually, they all stayed home, defecting to do the free love scene. Since they never defected from Mr. Bill, their only complaint must have been Monica’s inability to get a stain out of her dress; hardly anything to defect over.
I recieved on the 25 of april the collonel who asked asylum in this country. He needs real help, for his security Iwouldn’t tell in wich coountry is he now!
Azim