Get PJ Media on your Apple

Acts of God?

Reflections on “the cunning of reason.” Also read: Magic Underwear

David Solway


November 7, 2012 - 10:47 pm

During the 2008 election cycle, Republican standard-bearer John McCain was doing reasonably well in the polls — until the economic crisis intervened and eclipsed the conduct of the presidential race. McCain made the wrong decision; he suspended his campaign and headed to Washington, ostensibly to deal with the situation but just as likely to display his credentials as a concerned American.

Obama, on the contrary, stayed the course, presumably showing his dedication to the demands of the electoral process. The result was lamentably predictable: McCain lost his edge, looking more like someone who needed a break than like a responsible campaigner, and Obama reaped the rewards of his apparent diligence.

As we approached the critical moment of the 2012 election, with Republican challenger Mitt Romney mounting a strong performance and either tied with, or leading, an incumbent Obama in a number of national polls, Hurricane Sandy erupted, allowing Obama “to project an image of a president in charge at a time of crisis.”  What Hegel called “the cunning of reason” — by which he meant the sly purposes of history — was evident in the reversal of circumstance: whereas putting a campaign on hold sank McCain, it gave Obama a discernible boost. From one day to the next, Obama regained the advantage he was in the process of losing, as Reuters put it, to a now “subdued Romney.”

On the one hand, an economic meltdown occurred at precisely the moment to scuttle the better candidate’s prospects of election. On the other, barely a week before the voting stations closed, a veritable superstorm devastated vast swathes of the country, presenting an incompetent and highly suspect Obama with the opportunity to pose as a caring and paternal figure, and thus to sway the hearts of a too-impressionable electorate. Without doubt this was a decisive moment for the president.

If I were a betting man, I’d have been inclined to put my money on Obama. If I were a religious man, I would certainly have been tempted to believe that a vengeful God had turned his back on America, no longer in the divine view a shining city on a hill, but a moral and intellectual slum not worthy of His patronage. Since I am neither, I can only remark on the brutal and unforgiving irony of electoral politics.

Also read: Magic Underwear

(Photo by spirit of america /

David Solway is a Canadian poet and essayist. He is the author of The Big Lie: On Terror, Antisemitism, and Identity, and is currently working on a sequel, Living in the Valley of Shmoon. His new book on Jewish and Israeli themes, Hear, O Israel!, was released by Mantua Books. His latest book is The Boxthorn Tree, published in December 2012. Visit his Website at and his Facebook page here.
Click here to view the 44 legacy comments

Comments are closed.