I suggest it be done as follows. Let’s let the majority party in the state legislature take the first shot at proposing a redistricting plan. The sum of the irregularities of all the proposed districts can then be added up to create a score for the majority plan. The minority party can then be given 30 days to come up with an alternative plan. If they can come up with a design whose irregularity score is 1 percent lower than the majority plan, then the minority plan is adopted. If not, then the majority plan remains in place.
Creating districting boundaries in this way will not prevent the creation of safe districts for one party or another in all cases. But it will leave the matter to fair chance and geography, rather than the arbitrary actions of political cabals.
Under the current system, redistricting plans are subject to endless litigation, for example under the Voting Rights Act, wherein various minority groups have made the accusation that certain redistricting plans have been contrived to deny them representation. Alternatively, those facing such suits have made the counter argument that their proponents are attempting to create racially determined set-aside congressional seats, which would clearly be unconstitutional. However, if the system recommended here were adopted, both of these forms of improper activity would be impossible, and suits based upon their allegation thus rendered preposterous.
Many politicians will resist such reform, as it will cost them their ability to fix elections in their own favor. But dear state lawmakers please consider the following: This is your chance to do something great for America. The practice of gerrymandering is a national disgrace which has disenfranchised the majority of American voters from an effective voice in choosing their congressional representation for nearly two centuries. By taking the high road, you can set an example that will hold your counterparts in other states accountable as well, and set this criminal activity on the road to extinction. Instead of perpetuating corruption, you can use your time in office to accomplish something truly grand towards restoring democracy in America. It’s your choice. Think about it.