Get PJ Media on your Apple

A Most Catholic of Dramas

An Arizona woman, pregnant and suffering from pulmonary hypertension (an often fatal complication), consulted with her doctor and a Catholic Sister of Mercy, and obtained an abortion. The reactions have been predictable across religious and political lines.

by
Elizabeth Scalia

Bio

May 26, 2010 - 12:06 am
Page 1 of 2  Next ->   View as Single Page

In 2009 an Arizona woman, pregnant with her fifth child and suffering from pulmonary hypertension (an often, but not always fatal complication), consulted with her doctor and the ethics committee member on call — a Catholic Sister of Mercy — and obtained an abortion at the St. Joseph’s Hospital and Medical Center.

As the story has gone public, the reactions have been predictable across religious and political lines. Corrected by her bishop and currently reassigned in her duties, Sr. Margaret McBride, the administrator who participated in the undoubtedly difficult decision, has made no public statement on this issue. She is nevertheless being described as heroic by those who support the action, and denounced as suspicious by those who do not. Others are excoriating Bishop Thomas J. Olmsted, of the Diocese of Phoenix. With the heinous sins committed by pederast priests the forever-glaring standard of church-wide failure, critics wonder how a sister could be so quickly excommunicated, when so many bad priests were not. They cry “double standard” and “misogyny,” and wonder how the church can claim to have any moral authority left.

Well, because sometimes innocent people are convicted in America does not mean the nation cannot defend her laws, carefully crafted over time. Just so, the church’s having taken too long to right her own wrongs does not mean she surrenders the truths she has gleaned through faith and reason, over time. Making false equivalences does not bring clarity to McBride’s decision.

Like secular law, Catholic doctrine makes distinctions; it looks at intentions, opportunities and outcomes, direct and indirect causes; it understands that all things are not equal. It is difficult to explain to a feelings-led society that Sr. McBride conferred the latae sententiae (automatic) excommunication upon herself, and fully controls whether she will remain ex-communicated, or not, as doubtless she herself could explain. It may be unpleasant for some to hear, but participating in or procuring a direct, illicit abortion (as opposed to a licit, indirect abortion, as explained here) entails excommunication, while sexual abuse — gravely and mortally sinful — does not.

Click here to view the 50 legacy comments

Comments are closed.

3 Trackbacks to “A Most Catholic of Dramas”