Get PJ Media on your Apple

Ordered Liberty

Carter and Robinson: The Hamas Jihad’s Useful Idiots

August 6th, 2014 - 4:29 pm

Note, moreover, the stealthy hand of Iran in the mix. Hamas has had to come crawling back to the mullahs, hat in hand. After angering Tehran (and thus losing much of its funding and weapons support) by jumping on the Sunni side of the Syrian civil war, Hamas saw its preferred patron, the Muslim Brotherhood-dominated Egyptian regime, overthrown. The terrorist organization now finds itself opposed by the new anti-Brotherhood government in Cairo, and thus on the outs with that government’s backers in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. Isolated more than ever, Hamas is working hard to get back in Iran’s good graces. Its leaders conducted extensive meetings with top Iranian and Hezbollah officials prior to agreeing to cede governing authority over Gaza to the unity government. Carter and Robinson claim that this was a “major concession.” In truth, it was a coup, as Iran’s enthusiastic endorsement of the pact attests.

Tehran persuaded Hamas that, rather than mere domination of Gaza, its strategy should be to maintain de facto control while re-infiltrating Judea and Samaria (the West Bank, now controlled by Fatah). The authority over Gaza that was transferred to the unity government is only nominal. As the recent weeks of war amply demonstrate, Hamas still exercises actual control in Gaza through its security apparatus and the 50,000 civil servants it has installed. That is why, in elaborating on its “unity” agreement, Hamas emir Ismail Haniyeh crowed, “We leave the government but stay in power…. We give up the chair but not the role we play” in Gaza.

Meanwhile, Hamas has already begun making significant inroads in Fatah’s jurisdiction. And while Carter and Robinson make much of the fact that the unity government is a “technocratic” one with no Hamas members, they fail to mention that this is just a fleeting arrangement.

Hamas accepted it because the agreement also provides for elections in the next six months. The terrorists’ ambition is to compete with Fatah for every inch of the Palestinian territories and for control of the PLO – the Arafat creation that still represents Palestinians in dealings with Israel. Despite being temporarily out of formal governance, Hamas expects in short order to control key government ministries, just as Hezbollah does in Lebanon. Eventually, it expects to win a parliamentary majority and the presidency.

By taking on the appearance of a political party but maintaining its own, extra-governmental, Iran-backed military and intelligence force, Hamas gets the best of all terrorist worlds. Its participation in government enables anti-Israel Leftists like Carter and Robinson to echo claims by Islamic-supremacist strongmen like Turkey’s Recep Erdogan that Hamas is just a political party; yet, its jihadist arsenal allows it to intimidate any Palestinian opposition while continuing to terrorize Israel.

Equally laughable is Carter and Robinson’s contention that, by its agreement to the unity government, Hamas should be vicariously understood as assenting to the “technocratic” government’s agreement to the three Quartet conditions: “nonviolence, recognition of Israel, and adherence to past agreements.” In reality, as the war makes clear, the unity government is a ploy that enables Palestinians — who broadly and materially support Hamas’s jihad – to continue seeking Israel’s destruction while pretending to comply with the conditions on which the U.S. and Europe rely (nodding and winking) to rationalize billions in Palestinian aid.

Carter and Robinson are desperate to derive or otherwise manufacture Hamas’s purported agreement to the Quartet conditions because Hamas has made quite clear that it will never actually agree to renounce the jihad and accept Israel’s right to exist. The authors would cut Hamas slack on this score because, they say, the organization cannot be expected to “cooperate in its own demise.”

Even by loathsome Carter-Robinson standards, the assertion is breathtaking. The operating assumption of their op-ed is that Israel must cooperate in its own demise by ceasing to defend itself and abandoning the blockades absent which Hamas would quickly acquire even more deadly mass-destruction weapons. Furthermore, Hamas’ raison d’être is the annihilation of Israel by terrorist jihad; so by the authors’ reasoning, it could never be expected to agree to non-violent coexistence with a Jewish state since that would amount to the demise of Hamas.

Without the demise of Hamas, there is no chance for peace in the Middle East. It will require tuning out terror’s useful idiots.

(Artwork based on a modified Shutterstock.com image.)

<- Prev  Page 2 of 2   View as Single Page
Top Rated Comments   
I think you are being too kind by describing Carter and Robinson as "useful idiots". This implies that they have been duped.
They have not. Rather, they are evil people who know exactly what black and evil master they are serving.
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
Or, perhaps more fittingly, Dhimmi Carter.
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
James Earl Carter: A failure as president. A bumbling embarassment as ex-president. The State of Georgia offers profound apologies.
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
All Comments   (34)
All Comments   (34)
Sort: Newest Oldest Top Rated
Jihad Jimmy!
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
Any chance we can go back to the time when Jimmuh Carter was on "What's My Line" and nobody knew who he was?
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
Carter and Robinson are not useful idiots. They are useful collaborators.
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
I think you are being too kind by describing Carter and Robinson as "useful idiots". This implies that they have been duped.
They have not. Rather, they are evil people who know exactly what black and evil master they are serving.
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
Andy, when there's not prima facie evidence I look to follow the $$.

Who is getting greased here? Does Carter have a foundation? Robinson head up an NGO? It simply can't all be ideological with this brace of tools.

They are too far up the food chain for this to just be anti-Semitism.
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
Jimmy Carter needs to do us all a favor and go crawl under a porch to die like any other sick dog. Then obummer can make a big lionizing speech and we never have to hear the Jew hating imbecile open his mouth again.
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
Outstanding article, thanks Andrew.

It comes down to anti-semitism, there is no reason for either Carter or Robinson to be so blindly biased otherwise.
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
Time to trot out my Jimmy Carter joke.

Once, there were two brothers, a smart brother, and a dumb brother. One of the brothers was a good student, graduated from the Naval Academy, became a nuclear engineer, went into politics and was elected as Governor of Georgia, and then became the President of the United States. The smart brother had a beer named after him.
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
So Israel declined a reconciliation agreement in April and therefore
the present chaos is all Israel's fault.

I wonder how far along the construction of the tunnels was in April.
I guess Hamas was just building a subway system, thinking ahead to
reconciliation with Israel.
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
Carter should take Genesis 12:3 to heart:
"I will bless those who bless you ( Israel ) and
Curse those who curse you."
Hey Jimmy, say hello to Satan when you see him
Hopefully soon!
6 weeks ago
6 weeks ago Link To Comment
1 2 3 Next View All