An Unsealed Room

By Allison Kaplan Sommer

Get Updates From Allison Kaplan Sommer

War in Gaza is Hell…

January 1st, 2009 - 12:07 pm

It’s hard to find one word to describe what this war feels like. Such a mix of emotions. You see the pictures of the death and destruction in Gaza and you feel horrible – though none of us are exactly mourning the death of Hamas bigwig Nizar Rayyan. You talk to your friends in the south of the country and you feel guilty you aren’t doing more to help them. You practically beg them to come north and stay with you – not for them – for you, so you feel you are doing something.

I must say, the mood in central Israel – where we are lucky enough not to have our daily routines disrupted is one of calm, sober determination. And my friends in the south also seem impressively calm when I speak to them on the telephone. They are trying to be brave, even those who have never experienced anything like this before.

There is none of the sense of shock that we felt in Lebanon 2 when missiles began falling on Haifa and Tiberias and Rosh Pina. This time, there was preparation – carefully leaked stories were appearing in the Israeli press weeks before this operation started regarding the range of Hamas capabilities. This time, we weren’t surprised. We were prepared this time – not that being prepared to see your friends and family huddled in shelters fearing for their lives makes things a lot easier..

By hitting these major cities – Ashkelon, Ashdod, Beersheva, Yavne – the Hamas couldn’t be doing a better job of convincing Israel that it has to dig in its heels and not give up until the message is clear – we can’t do this anymore. We won’t play this game. The Kassam and now the Grad missile threat isn’t just pesky anymore. It’s inhuman and unbearable.

The image that keeps coming to mind is a man holding a gun being taunted by an angry twisted kid with an unlimited supply of darts. At first, he teasingly tosses the darts at the soldier’s feet gently. Then gradually he throws them harder, drawing blood, creating more serious wounds. And then, eventually, getting bolder, he starts aiming for the abdomen, private parts, even the man’s eyes, looking to do real damage. After the man asks, requests, demands, tries to negotiate, swats, kicks – does everything in his power to stop this constant barrage, which is clearly taking place in the hopes that he will eventually bleed to death. At some point – no matter how calm, civilized and intelligent this man might be – the pain is going to be too much. As unfair, as ‘disproportionate’ as it may be, he’s going to pull out his gun and use it. And that’s the point Israel has reached. Enough. We’ve had enough.

Let me say it again – we see the pictures from Gaza. Trust me, there is no joy, elation, or victory in the Israeli streets when we see crushed buildings and bleeding civilians. Not even a little. We are grim, we are sad, we so wish that it hadn’t had to come to this. But the vast, vast majority of us just don’t see any other way right now.

We just can’t live like this anymore. Take a look at this video and ask yourself if you could.

By the way, nobody is taking any chances. Despite the fact that, to the best of the IDF’s knowledge – Hamas doesn’t have rockets capable of reaching them – people located points north of Ashdod and Yavne – in Rishon Le Zion and in Tel Aviv are cleaning out their shelters. Just in case.

Gaza the Lab Experiment

January 1st, 2009 - 8:41 am

Victor Davis Hanson:

Gaza is a sort of lab experiment in the Middle East. Recall for a minute: the Israelis withdrew en masse, a so-called “retreat” that reverberated all over the Middle East. The West supported free and open elections that gave Hamas their legitimacy, such as it was. Gaza is strategically placed on the Mediterranean with a prime shoreline. It borders Egypt the traditional center of the Arab world. Hundreds of millions of dollars of Middle-East oil money, and Western relief donations have poured into the tiny state. Israeli clearly wants no more of it, and would love to let Gaza alone to be Dubai.

The result?

Hamas with its serial rocket attacks on Israel interprets all of the above not as an opportunity for prosperity, but as a stage one for the great accomplishment of its generation—the absolute destruction of the Jewish state. Its agenda is clear and unambiguous, and apparently shared by millions of elites in the West itself, without whose support Hamas could not exist. The common theme of Western press coverage is the misery of Gaza, never the misery of Gaza as a product of the garrison-state mentality of Hamas’s radical Islamic vows to wage perennial war against Israel.

The Enablers

Hamas counts on the fact that its own losses will be characterized as a “holocaust” and appear comparable in the Western media to something like Darfur or the slaughtering in Zimbabwe, or the usual carnage that we wake up to on the news. Take away Western press attention from Gaza, and Hamas is just another violent, illiberal regime that impoverishes its own people while seeking victim status in the West.

Is that too harsh? I don’t think so. Again, if it were to call a one-year truce with Israel, seek normal relations with Egypt, and swear off Iranian-Hezbollah terrorist aid while it sought to rebuild infrastructure, ensure security, and recruit foreign capital, then there would be no more world attention, and its cadres of hooded youth would lack the pizzazz of “militants.”

Survivor and Survival

December 31st, 2008 - 2:43 pm

We’re heavy-duty into the second season of the Israeli ‘Survivor’ and my kids are big fans. All day there’s been war coverage, but in prime time, the television networks are allowing themselves a few hours of making profits, and that includes reality television.

So we’re watching this evening, the action is getting intense as one of the Survivor tribes has yet to build a fire, can’t boil water, and is seriously thirsty. Suddenly, Channel 10 cuts away for a quick update on the latest falling missiles. My ten year old daughter Naomi groans, “I don’t watch the news, I want to watch the people SUFFERING.” She corrects herself quickly: “I mean, I want to see the people suffering on the ISLAND, I don’t want to see the people suffering in the SOUTH…”

What if Gaza Was in Mexico?

December 31st, 2008 - 2:06 pm

I’ve been using this analogy for years now when I’ve been interviewed on radio and TV. It’s interesting to see it illustrated so dramatically on video.

(I really, really wish the Israeli who made it had let a native speaker go over the English, though. “Neighboors has missiles”? “Very Far Targets?”)

Comments Off bullet bullet

Been Here, Done This

December 31st, 2008 - 8:36 am

Another case of déjà vu. Here I am at the pool club where I spent much of the Second Lebanon War glued to the TV news along with the other worried adults while the kids frolicked obliviously.

And what is on TV right now?

Commentators on the news talking about the air attacks on Gaza, reviewing the damage of missile attacks on Israel, and speculating when the ground invasion will begin. I hate reruns…

(This was my first blog post ever created away from the computer, on the iPhone…)

Comments Off bullet bullet

Kids Are Back From School And…

December 31st, 2008 - 7:11 am

It sort of sounds like they got a mixed message.

First they were told there was ‘zero’ chance missiles could hit Ra’anana where we live. Then they did an emergency exercise regarding what to do if there was a missile attack. Hmmm.

They did one in my youngest daughter’s pre-K as well.

Their elementary school is opening its doors to any friends and family members of students in the south of the country who are staying here – they can come attend school here, too (I bet the kids are just THRILLED to hear that – not) My daughter’s fourth-grade class had guest students today – relatives of her teacher.

Comments Off bullet bullet

Paging Dr. Terror…

December 31st, 2008 - 6:02 am

Israeli television just reported that the leadership of Hamas are running scared. Some are hiding in bunkers, some escaping through tunnels to Egypt, and some hanging out in the hospitals on the assumption Israel won’t risk the public relations disaster of hitting one of them. To be extra careful, they are putting on white robes to blend in with the hospital staff….

You go, girl

(And if Liza doesn’t convince you, there’s always Amos Oz and A.B. Yehoshua)

The Stories You Won’t See on CNN

December 31st, 2008 - 3:10 am

For the benefit of readers outside Israel, I’ll share the anecdotes that aren’t likely to make it into the mainstream news overseas. There’s more to this war than just explosions.

Solidarity

The silver lining on the terrible conflicts and wars here is the solidarity and spirit that you see emanating from people. Last night on the news, there was a segment with the proprieter of a small hotel in the north of the country who was offering free respite vacations to people from the south in rocket range, no charge. In general, families in the north who were the recipients of generosity in the past - from people willing to host them in the Center and South of the country are reciprocating.

Sportsmanship

Soccer and basketball teams in other parts of the country are offering their fields and homes to their counterparts in the south so they can continue to practice and compete. On the radio, the African-American star foreign player for Ashkelon’s professional basketball team, a guy named Steve Burtt, said that his family hadn’t wanted him to fly back to Israel after the Christmas holidays. But he came back anyway. He said, “The fans in Ashkelon support me and stand by me, I decided I had to support them, and stand by them.”

Good for you, Steve.

Comedy

The brave comics of Israel’s Saturday Night Live, a show called Eretz Nehederet, dared to go on the air last night and attempt satire while the missiles were falling. And they managed to be hilarious – and only slightly tasteless. To demonstrate the wartime solidarity, they had Bibi Netanyahu and Tsippi Livni in army uniforms recreating the romantic final scene of “An Officer and the Gentleman” declaring that this was no time for politics. But then of course, they couldn’t hold themselves back and the insults started flying: “If I weren’t rising above politics, I’d be calling you a conceited, incompetent….”

They made fun of Israeli TV’s gung-ho military reporter Roni Daniel, showing him reporting dressed as Rambo, calling out the number of those killed on either side as if they were sports scores.

The whole show was framed by a typical Israeli family watching the events on television, and finally having to leave their living room when a siren sounded warning they needed to be in the bomb shelter in 45 seconds. They rushed around the room grabbing their most treasured possessions – including their flat-screen TV, which they ripped out of the wall – and then the room was deserted.

As the show ended and the credits rolled, the father of the family re-entered the house at the last minute for something they had forgotten – their kid. Oops.

Technology

They were calling the Second Lebanon War the first war to be blogged. This Gaza operation is the first to be Twittered.

War in the Age of Facebook

December 31st, 2008 - 2:10 am

My friend Faye, who works in Beersheva, is updating her friends via her Facebook status…

Her last update:

Faye Bittker is fine, but will feel better if we could actually hear the sirens here in Beer-sheva (we just hear from the TV that there is a siren).

 

Comments Off bullet bullet